<p>The rules as written aren't completely unambiguous, but their meaning can be determined.</p>

<blockquote>
  <p><strong>Riots</strong> - Every player who controls a major city must roll a die, adding 1 to their roll for each troop and HQ <strong>in that territory</strong>. If your modified roll is lower than 6, remove troops equal to your natural die roll and DEMOLISH any HQs in that territory. DISCARD this card.</p>
</blockquote>

<p>1) <strong>Yes</strong>, the Riots event only kills troops in Major Cities. <strong>Yes</strong>, it is possible to lose the last troop in a territory this way. (I.e. You have 2 troops + an HQ and roll a natural '2'.)</p>

<p>2) This is ambiguous. I would roll for each Major City independently, counting troops and HQs in each territory independently, but the rules as written state that players only roll once, and calculate their modified roll independently for each territory.</p>

<p>3) This is a good reason to only roll one die regardless of how many Major City territories you control and calculate individual modified rolls based upon the number of troops and HQs in independent territories. (I.e. You roll a natural '1' and have one Major City with 4 troops and an HQ in it and one Major City with 2 troops. Riots would remove the HQ and one troop from one territory and one troop from the other territory.)</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-12-13T17:04:34.467Z
In our game we rolled once and used that same rolled number to apply to each territory individually. There is no way to somehow avoid your HQ being destroyed by specifying a different territory instead.
Daniel Lim
CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-07-16T05:08:53.837Z
2015-07-16T05:08:53.837Z
user1873
<p>The "Riots" card has three ambiguities:</p>

<ol>
<li>Do the troops that get removed have to die in the "major city" territory or just from anywhere controlled by that player? Can the last troop in a territory get removed in this way?</li>
<li>If a player owns two major cities, do the troops on both major cities count towards the total, or just one of them, or each of them independently?</li>
<li>If a player owns two major cities and has an HQ on one of them, does the HQ get destroyed, or is it possible to consider the other major city as the "territory" in question?</li>
</ol>

<risk-legacy>
Risk Legacy "Riots" event card is ambigious
Alexey
# Risk Legacy "Riots" event card is ambigious

(Asked by: username_0 on 2015-07-14)

The "Riots" card has three ambiguities:

1. Do the troops that get removed have to die in the "major city" territory or just from anywhere controlled by that player? Can the last troop in a territory get removed in this way?
2. If a player owns two major cities, do the troops on both major cities count towards the total, or just one of them, or each of them independently?
3. If a player owns two major cities and has an HQ on one of them, does the HQ get destroyed, or is it possible to consider the other major city as the "territory" in question?

**Tags:** risk-legacy


---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2015-07-16. Score: 2

The rules as written aren't completely unambiguous, but their meaning can be determined.

> **Riots** - Every player who controls a major city must roll a die, adding 1 to their roll for each troop and HQ **in that territory**. If your modified roll is lower than 6, remove troops equal to your natural die roll and DEMOLISH any HQs in that territory. DISCARD this card.

1) **Yes**, the Riots event only kills troops in Major Cities. **Yes**, it is possible to lose the last troop in a territory this way. (I.e. You have 2 troops + an HQ and roll a natural '2'.)

2) This is ambiguous. I would roll for each Major City independently, counting troops and HQs in each territory independently, but the rules as written state that players only roll once, and calculate their modified roll independently for each territory.

3) This is a good reason to only roll one die regardless of how many Major City territories you control and calculate individual modified rolls based upon the number of troops and HQs in independent territories. (I.e. You roll a natural '1' and have one Major City with 4 troops and an HQ in it and one Major City with 2 troops. Riots would remove the HQ and one troop from one territory and one troop from the other territory.)

> **Comments:**
> **username_2**: In our game we rolled once and used that same rolled number to apply to each territory individually. There is no way to somehow avoid your HQ being destroyed by specifying a different territory instead.  

---

