<p>There are lots of different versions of the rules, so it is hard to give an exact quote and page reference, but they all agree on the resolution of this. The version I found says "A unit moves with its own strength combined with all of its valid supports. Unless it is opposed by a unit that is equally or better supported, it can complete its move." In this case Bohemia was opposed by a better supported unit, so it cannot complete its move and stays in Bohemia.</p>

<p>So in the case that two or more attacks occur on the same province, and one is stronger than all the others as well as being stronger than the existing defense, the strongest attack succeeds and the others all fail. Any units participating in those attacks remain where they were (unless they are dislodged by a different attack on their own province) and any units that started in the attacked province are dislodged and will need to retreat. You can only be dislodged from the province that you started the turn in.</p>

<p>If there are multiple attacks on the same province, and there are two or more attacks tied for the strongest (or tied with the existing defense), then all the attacks fail. This can result in an unsupported defender holding a province against two supported attacks as long as the supported attacks are of equal strength.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-05-02T04:17:43.563Z
I believe the latest rulebook is at http://www.wizards.com/avalonhill/rules/diplomacy_rulebook.pdf which is probably the best to cite.
Peter McNamara
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-04-18T13:29:07.927Z
2018-04-18T13:38:04.140Z
2018-04-18T13:38:04.140Z
bwarner
<p>I'm the gamemaster for a diplomacy game played between a couple of friends, and we encountered a situation where we didn't really agree. I've looked through the rules and searched the internet, but I still couldn't find an answer.</p>

<p>What happens if two forces of unequal strength attack the same province? 
The rulebook clarifies that an underpowered unit in such a situation has to make a retreat move, but it doesn't seem to mention what happens if there is no defending unit, only attacking units.</p>

<p>To clarify the situation I'll give you an example:</p>

<p>Germany:</p>

<ol>
<li>A War - Gal</li>
<li>A Sil S A War - Gal</li>
</ol>

<p>Russia:</p>

<ol>
<li>A Boh - Gal</li>
</ol>

<p>Here we see that Germany's attacking force is stronger than Russia's, and there are 2 possibilities (I think) of what happens next arises. Either the unit in Bohemia stays in Bohemia and the unit in Warsaw moves to Galicia, or the unit in Bohemia has moves to Galicia where it then has to make a retreat move and the unit from Warsaw stays in Galicia.</p>

<p>Is there any rule that I have overlooked which answers my question, or do you have any opinions of what might be the proper way to handle the situation?</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-04-18T13:13:09.407Z
Welcome to Board & Card Games Stack Exchange! Great first question!
Thunderforge
<diplomacy>
What happens if two forces of unequal strength attacks the same province?
Hahagaga12
# What happens if two forces of unequal strength attacks the same province?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2018-04-18)

I'm the gamemaster for a diplomacy game played between a couple of friends, and we encountered a situation where we didn't really agree. I've looked through the rules and searched the internet, but I still couldn't find an answer.

What happens if two forces of unequal strength attack the same province?
The rulebook clarifies that an underpowered unit in such a situation has to make a retreat move, but it doesn't seem to mention what happens if there is no defending unit, only attacking units.

To clarify the situation I'll give you an example:

Germany:

1. A War - Gal
2. A Sil S A War - Gal

Russia:

1. A Boh - Gal

Here we see that Germany's attacking force is stronger than Russia's, and there are 2 possibilities (I think) of what happens next arises. Either the unit in Bohemia stays in Bohemia and the unit in Warsaw moves to Galicia, or the unit in Bohemia has moves to Galicia where it then has to make a retreat move and the unit from Warsaw stays in Galicia.

Is there any rule that I have overlooked which answers my question, or do you have any opinions of what might be the proper way to handle the situation?

**Tags:** diplomacy

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Welcome to Board & Card Games Stack Exchange! Great first question!  

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_2 on 2018-04-18. Score: 12 | Accepted answer

There are lots of different versions of the rules, so it is hard to give an exact quote and page reference, but they all agree on the resolution of this. The version I found says "A unit moves with its own strength combined with all of its valid supports. Unless it is opposed by a unit that is equally or better supported, it can complete its move." In this case Bohemia was opposed by a better supported unit, so it cannot complete its move and stays in Bohemia.

So in the case that two or more attacks occur on the same province, and one is stronger than all the others as well as being stronger than the existing defense, the strongest attack succeeds and the others all fail. Any units participating in those attacks remain where they were (unless they are dislodged by a different attack on their own province) and any units that started in the attacked province are dislodged and will need to retreat. You can only be dislodged from the province that you started the turn in.

If there are multiple attacks on the same province, and there are two or more attacks tied for the strongest (or tied with the existing defense), then all the attacks fail. This can result in an unsupported defender holding a province against two supported attacks as long as the supported attacks are of equal strength.

> **Comments:**
> **username_3**: I believe the latest rulebook is at http://www.wizards.com/avalonhill/rules/diplomacy_rulebook.pdf which is probably the best to cite.  

---

