‘Privacy is a Fundamental Right’: Advocates Hail India’s Supreme Court Ruling · Global Voices
Biometric data collection center in India. Photo by <PERSON> via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)
The right to privacy — on the internet and everywhere else — has become “intrinsic to [the] right to life,” in the words of India's supreme court.
After years of debate, a panel of nine judges gave this historic verdict on the morning of August 24. The court unanimously ruled that privacy is a fundamental right and will thus become part of the Article 21 and Part 3 of India's constitution, which details the Right to Life and Personal Liberty.
The verdict was handed down after the court considered multiple citizen petitions that challenged the government's move to make Aadhaar — India's national digital ID system — mandatory for various social welfare benefits.
Legal experts and digital rights advocates have been sharing excerpts from the 547-page ruling and hailing the decision on Twitter:
More love! #RightToPrivacy pic.twitter.com/mLcG5YdUo4
— <PERSON> (@Mayank1029) August 24, 2017
The nine judge bench of the Supreme Court has unanimusly held that privacy is a fundamental right under the Indian Constitution.
— <PERSON> (@gautambhatia88) August 24, 2017
This is a 9-0 unanimous ruling #RightToPrivacy India.
— <PERSON> (@MishiChoudhary) August 24, 2017
Administrated by the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI), a statutory authority, the Aadhaar system requires citizens to disclose significant amounts of personal and biometric data to the government.
Prior to the ruling, UIDAI declared that privacy is not a fundamental right and assured the public that data in the Aadhaar system was being sufficiently safeguarded.
Yet technical problems in the system have brought serious consequences for the public. System malfunctions have led to massive leaks of citizens’ data (affecting an estimated 130 million people), and have left low-income people unable to receive state food subsidies.
Activists, lawyers, petitioners and many individuals are celebrating the supreme court's verdict on social media with the hashtag #RightToPrivacy, and many also foresee that Aadhaar will soon be in jeopardy. The ruling even compared the Aadhaar system to government wiretapping of private citizens’ telephones.
The verdict has raised the hopes of those who are against Aadhaar. Some have mistaken the verdict as a ruling against Aadhaar, which it is not.
Not yet sir … Can't say Aadhar gone yet !!
— अखण्ड विराट भारतीय (@RAJ_KUMAR_VERMA) August 24, 2017
But the battle may be won, but this is *not* a judgement on #Aadhaar. But earlier judgments state that the CB judgment will have a bearing
— <PERSON> (@saikatd) August 24, 2017
<PERSON>, a lawyer and human rights advocate based in New Delhi, cautioned that the future of Aadhaar was still subject to authorities’ interpretation of the ruling and subsequent court decisions:
Privacy case irrespective of result will need to be applied to Aadhaar. Will be by subsequent benches. 607
We will succeed by persistence. 2/2
— Apar (@aparatbar) August 24, 2017
A definite cause for celebration, but we cannot proclaim victory. The true test will be an application which will draw out legal nuance.
— <PERSON> (@aparatbar) August 24, 2017
The current government, run by right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party, was not pleased with the verdict as it will directly impact the way private data is collected and shared in India. The ruling party has promoted Aadhaar as a core project of the Digital India campaign.
Also note to gushy cheerleaders <PERSON> govt had actually told the court that citizens did not have right to privacy. #RightToPrivacy
— <PERSON> (@bainjal) August 24, 2017
There have arguably been multiple attempts to silence those who went public pointing out the issues with Aadhaar. Some of the most well-researched critiques of the system have come from the Centre for Internet and Society (CIS), an inter-disciplinary research organisation in Bangalore that has become a target of the pro-Aadhaar lobby. Shortly after CIS released a report that pointed to security flaws in the Aadhaar ecosystem, the UIDAI accused the organization of hacking into the Aadhaar system themselves.
The UIDAI has gone after other critics as well, including the creator of a video blog post that showed about the vulnerability of Aadhaar data. In response, the UIDAI accused the creator of violating Section 37 of the Aadhaar Act. 607