Patient recruitment and screening The CREST study will be performed at the Mayo Clinic (Rochester, MN and Arizona campus), the American Hip Institute (Chicago, IL). The surgeons coordinating this study have performed over 5,000 hip arthroscopies collectively. They have shown the ability to recruit patients to perform these procedures and demonstrated the ability to follow these patients for 2 years or longer in order to assess outcomes. They are planning to start enrolling patients in January of 2017 and continue the enrollment process on an ongoing basis. Patients will be classified based on three categories: 1) Included in the study and randomized 2) excluded if they do not meet the inclusion criteria, or 3) Missed (patients that were eligible but not included in the study due to an error or limited staff availability at the time of presentation).