Appropriately selected patients with histologically documented recurrence 3 years or more after initial external beam radiotherapy will undergo mpMRI for identification of the site of recurrence. A planning transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) will be obtained for fusion with the mpMRI and transposition of the target volume (GTV=gross tumor volume). A margin of 4.5 cm will be added to the GTV to create a focal planning target volume (PTV). The margin may be cropped at the interface with critical organs. Two fractions of HDR brachytherapy will be delivered, each from a single implant, 2 weeks apart. Following treatment patients will be monitored for toxicity and quality of life using the Expanded Prostate cancer Index (EPIC) questionnaire as well as the International Prostate Symptom score. Efficacy will be evaluated by monitoring the Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA) and repeat mpMRI at 2 years.