مــن لجنــة القانون الدولي &quot; )اﻷمم المتحدة، نيويورك، ١٩٩٧(( ومن بين اﻵراء المخالفة التي أعرب عنها أعضاء حاليون أو سابقون في اللجنة ما يلـي: R. Rosentock, &quot; An International Criminal Responsibility of States? &quot; , ibid, p. 265; D.W. Bowett, &quot; Crimes of State and the 1996 Report of the International Law Commission on State Responsibility &quot; EJIL, 1998, p. 163; I Brownlie, State Responsibility, System of the Law of Nations, Part I (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1983), pp. 32-33; B Simma, &quot; From Bilateralism to Community .Interest in International Law &quot; Receuil des cours (...) vol. 250 (1994, pp. 301-321
Des thèses opposées ont été présentées par des commentateurs qui ont siégé ou siègent à la Commission, entre autres R. Rosentock, «An International Criminal Responsibility of States?», ibid., p. 265; D. W. Bowett, «Crimes of States and the 1996 Report of the International law Commission on State Responsibility», EJIL, 1998, p. 163; L. Brownlie, State Responsibility, System of the Law of Nations, Part I (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1983), p. 32 et 33; B. Simma, «From Bilateralism to Community Interest in International Law», Recueil des cours, vol. 250 (1994), p. 301 à 321. .