summarize the discussion on evaluation criteria of remote control .[SEP] <s>project manager: good . industrial designer: beep . oh . project manager: so well uh user interface: what ? project manager: welcome everyone . user interface: yeah . project manager: um as you may have noticed i uh user interface: industrial designer: project manager: created separate folders because it was uh tending to get a little busy in our uh shared project documents uh folder . user interface: yeah . project manager: i do n't know if everybody uh put their own uh documents in the right folder , which is for now the detailed design meeting . marketing: that 's new one ? project manager: yeah . user interface: we did n't make any uh industrial designer: uh , we should save that one . user interface: oh in project manager: then i 'll move this one . user interface: did n't we just do that ? industrial designer: yeah , save in the folder . save as project . user interface: oh . project manager: oh no , this is just one big document , so you can leave that wherever it is . industrial designer: oh , okay . project manager: and we have a evaluation left here . user interface: industrial designer: hmm hmm . project manager: okay . industrial designer: agenda . project manager: well not main documents this time . oh uh yes . user interface: hmm ? project manager: i have it open myself i guess . um well the detailed design meeting huh ? we 're finally getting somewhere hopefully . industrial designer: user interface: project manager: um what are we going to do ? i 've opened it already . um i 'm still going to take some minutes , and if i 'm right , you two are going to give a prototype presentation ? industrial designer: oh , sorry . marketing: industrial designer: project manager: are n't you ? user interface: we could . project manager: yes , you are . industrial designer: project manager: and uh m did you do something with evaluation criteria ? marketing: yep . yep . project manager: good . and we have a correct agenda . and uh then we have to look at something which is less nice , the finance uh aspect , whether we can afford what we have designed , user interface: oops . project manager: and if we can we can uh commence the final part which is the production or project evaluation , how did we work together and what are the results , and how happy are we with those . okay , well finance uh will be later . now i 'd like to give the word to you two . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: okay . user interface: well uh industrial designer: get up stand up . just user interface: we made a prototype . industrial designer: 'kay . user interface: we first start with the overall uh this is about the total remote control . industrial designer: view . user interface: we made it green . industrial designer: just example colour , user interface: yeah . industrial designer: so uh there 's one of the colours we would like to uh see in our prototype . user interface: it 's a fresh colour . and uh the screen light blue . oh uh this the scroll button and the microphone on the on the sides here under . and the r_ and r_ logo , it just says r_ and r_ now , but uh industrial designer: okay ? user interface: any questions so far ? marketing: big microphone . industrial designer: yeah , user interface: yeah . industrial designer: just uh just an idea about how to m th that could also be possible . marketing: oh okay . that 's the place where it 's going to be , not the size . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: uh well , it 's an idea in a so . user interface: oh y you perhaps you should make it a bit big , so people know it 's there and uh industrial designer: do not forget it . user interface: uh marketing: mm-hmm . industrial designer: to function it it does n't really have to be sm uh big of course . user interface: hmm . marketing: yeah , okay . of course . industrial designer: the microphone could be just a minor uh hole uh on the left uh button . marketing: mm . mm , th yeah . industrial designer: okay um marketing: small . industrial designer: we also made some uh ideas about how uh the options menu would work . uh using the scroll button on sides uh y uh i uh um user interface: you push the scroll button industrial designer: yeah , you push the scroll button user interface: and it 's claps out if there 's a industrial designer: and a drop down menu or a pull out menu comes out and uh you get uh you get the options uh becoming available . for example uh tv settings , uh remote settings , et cetera . user interface: remote settings , et cetera . yeah . industrial designer: so uh you can scroll down too with the scroll uh button , uh as you can see oh , it 's here , just push it in , uh the menu comes out like this and uh i it all becomes visible . um user interface: yeah . and you could also touch it so that it comes out , industrial designer: yeah , that 's c user interface: and and use the the the scroll thing as a with your fingers . industrial designer: yeah . indeed . user interface: yes . industrial designer: okay , um it 's also uh nice to see that um we made a small uh menu , uh the options menu uh becoming available when pressing the uh scroll uh button , and the opportunity to use the teletext , whi which is used uh which should still be used and we think that it 's uh very handy to put it uh not uh under the options menu , but in uh yes . in an apart uh user interface: yeah . project manager: so a separate button for for text , industrial designer: in a separate button , yeah . user interface: yeah . project manager: okay . user interface: perhaps we should use the teletext sign in p yeah . industrial designer: a sign , yeah , just like okay , indeed . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: okay , user interface: forgot . industrial designer: we can uh modify that later . okay . would you like to make any comments about next uh user interface: uh well , this is the total interface uh that f of the lcd screen . uh the numbers , which is pretty straight forward . we put ano an an extra button in . we can erase it , but it 's the button where you can switch channels . just when you are one and you go to two , you can or if you go to five , you can go back to one with that button . yeah , that one , yeah . industrial designer: previous page , yeah , indeed . user interface: it has a name . and uh uh we put that in , industrial designer: oh my god . user interface: i thought it would be handy there . uh this the one number or two numbers button . below that , the page and the sound . and uh in the middle the the mute . uh battery indicator . industrial designer: it 's quite large . user interface: it 's it 's a bit big . marketing: user interface: and this is the uh the on off uh knop , the stand by uh knop . or at least it should look like it . and the options uh of teletext . industrial designer: okay . you can see very clearly now that the uh teletext and options menu is n't uh taking uh much uh uh it 's taking much part of the screen , so it 's very uh when you uh when you use it , does n't uh become irritating to see . user interface: huh . industrial designer: 'cause if you put it on the top you always get see the the options menu . 'cause people regularly uh read from left top to right down , project manager: mm-hmm . industrial designer: so user interface: yeah . well this about it , i think . industrial designer: okay . huh . user interface: yeah . project manager: thank you . looks good . user interface: i will put it back on the on the nice green . industrial designer: project manager: and i just missed when i was typing the r_r_ stands for ? industrial designer: user interface: that 's the logo of the project manager: logo , okay . user interface: yeah . it 's th th right now it 's only r_ r_ , but uh marketing: project manager: okay well industrial designer: full screen . project manager: i would have recognised it if it were the right colours of course . marketing: shit . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: alright . user interface: sorry . marketing: 'kay . project manager: okay , the evaluation criteria , user interface: oh full screen , yeah . industrial designer: huh . project manager: huh ? marketing: evaluation . 'kay , my task was this time to put up a questionnaire by which we can evaluate the design of the remote control by the questions we requirements from the of the users . my name , my job , okay . industrial designer: my name , my job . user interface: marketing: the methods . questionnaire with seven point scale from one to seven , from true to false , user interface: right . marketing: like question , is remote big enough , we can say it 's true or it 's false by steps . one means absolutely not true , seven means true . user interface: yeah . marketing: the three important things of refa are uh from th of this year is are , industrial designer: sorry , user interface: industrial designer: you used the powerpoint marketing: is the remote control fancy enough , user interface: yeah . marketing: is it in innovative enough , and is it easy enough to use . and then evaluation itself . uh . user interface: industrial designer: what ? marketing: so . industrial designer: bling . marketing: okay . user interface: yeah . marketing: first question . is the design fancy enough ? user interface: well marketing: project manager , what do you think ? project manager: well it 's looks fancy , especially with the green colour . and the the curves which we decided , user interface: yeah . marketing: but does it project manager: huh ? marketing: yeah . project manager: only what happened to the single curve we spoke about last meeting ? user interface: it uh oh it 's in the background . oh . industrial designer: now uh the single curved idea was uh yeah , okay , you ge um user interface: y you should make uh a sideways uh view . industrial designer: yeah . the sideways view , uh that that that ma user interface: it will be , i guess . oh , we can industrial designer: ho not that pen . not that pen . user interface: oh marketing: project manager: well user interface: g i would smart board . project manager: it might work one time , huh . industrial designer: suppose so . user interface: uh can i draw here or uh marketing: think . user interface: ooh . industrial designer: ah . oh my god , marketing: yeah , yeah , you can . user interface: so it would be uh something like this from the side , but with a bit of uh curve here , industrial designer: it works . user interface: right ? industrial designer: yeah , that 's the single curve indeed . user interface: yeah . so if you v flip it like this . project manager: okay . industrial designer: yep . user interface: here 's yeah . industrial designer: that 's not very i it 's also uh very handy if you make a side curve way to make the the remote control very thin at the bottom uh at a bottom at a bottom . uh make it uh rather thick on the top , because uh on the top it has uh the screen , which takes uh in some uh space , and the batteries can be located over there , user interface: yeah . so you just make the back of this part a bit bigger , industrial designer: so uh user interface: so that it lays a bit o industrial designer: yeah . marketing: is n't going to be a little bit heavy at the top ? industrial designer: user interface: yeah , that 's a bit of problem maybe . marketing: industrial designer: no . marketing: with two batteries , the whole print plate and t and top , and if you 're holding it quite a lot i think user interface: yeah . i think yeah , the battery should be in here , because it 's just nothing , industrial designer: yeah . user interface: so if you could marketing: yeah . industrial designer: okay , indeed . yeah . user interface: yeah . project manager: okay , but we have to rate uh these things now ? user interface: 'cause otherwise i think i marketing: yeah , we have to rate . project manager: okay . marketing: is it fancy enough ? true is one , false is seven . so fancy enough means , does it comes to the younger people and the elder people . user interface: i think it does . industrial designer: i think so . user interface: i if you do n't make it green , then the elder people wo n't wo n't like it . industrial designer: it 's pretty fancy . marketing: i think yeah , i have to agree , all the colour colours don don does n't matter that m that much now , user interface: yeah . industrial designer: you get th project manager: mm-hmm . marketing: it 's only design . user interface: i think it does . project manager: yeah . marketing: and the design . project manager: well i think uh especially because of the microphone and the lcd screen also . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: yeah . i do n't know whether older people will use it , but project manager: very new thing . well fancy the old people will . marketing: so user interface: i would make it a two or something . industrial designer: marketing: a two ? user interface: yeah . industrial designer: it 's true , it 's a one . very fancy . user interface: huh ? alright , it 's a one . oh it 's a one . project manager: no , it 's a two . little bit strange we have to judge that ourselves , huh ? user interface: yeah . marketing: yeah , i n used i wouldn i should use that one , but it does n't industrial designer: user interface: but it 's a one uh maybe uh marketing: okay , no it 's two ? true is a one . user interface: yeah . marketing: very true , is it very true or is n't that true ? project manager: well i 'd say two on a scale user interface: well they think it 's very true , but uh industrial designer: it 's very true , because we designed it to be very fancy , marketing: yeah , i think two . user interface: yeah , industrial designer: so user interface: but industrial designer: it 's very fancy , i think . user interface: we should perhaps industrial designer: have you ever seen a remote control like this ? project manager: no , okay well , that 's true . industrial designer: no , okay , user interface: that not . industrial designer: so so it 's fancy . marketing: that 's fancy enough . user interface: yeah . project manager: okay , one two . marketing: then ? project manager: that does n't matter that much , so make it a one . user interface: industrial designer: yeah . marketing: okay . let 's give it a two . is it innovative ? user interface: i think it is , marketing: enough . project manager: yeah user interface: because it has an lcd screen , a mi microphone . project manager: m industrial designer: and uh uh the scroll is rubber , user interface: it 's from rubber . marketing: we have for the search function . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: so s eno enough to i think . marketing: the scroller a bit i think it 's it 's a one yeah . user interface: it 's a one i think . industrial designer: marketing: true . also huh uh-huh the buttons , are they easy to find ? that was a big requirement of the old people . industrial designer: user interface: yeah , because they 're right on your screen . so you can use the b the the arrows . they 're right on your screen , industrial designer: huh . user interface: so i do n't know where you 'd search . industrial designer: with the ones marketing: are all the buttons easy to find ? not only this buttons , all the buttons . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: user interface: well , i think they are . the options are it uh little bit harder , industrial designer: yeah . user interface: but if you touch the options then it 's uh industrial designer: take a harder look , yeah , sure . marketing: i think th it 's industrial designer: it 's easier than the regular uh remote control . marketing: easy t project manager: yeah , and you use these buttons the most , marketing: yeah , i think this is easy now . i think th i think the options buttons are not the the easiest way to to project manager: huh ? so industrial designer: yeah . user interface: no they 're not , but they 're they 're they are easy to find . marketing: to handle . true . industrial designer: yeah , they are a lot easier to find than uh th than on the regular remote controls marketing: i would rate it a user interface: oh . industrial designer: where you have to uh find out what which sign or icon means on uh every button . marketing: yeah , okay , that 's true , that 's true . user interface: yeah . project manager: so industrial designer: so you have t you have to use the the the manual to understand most project manager: which marketing: but that 's that 's vantage of lcd screen , you can have text . project manager: so which number are we going to fill in ? industrial designer: yeah . user interface: i would say yeah . industrial designer: i think it 's uh it 's a two , at least . user interface: yeah . yeah , project manager: a two , yeah ? user interface: you can make it a two . project manager: two , three and industrial designer: it 's not perfect , but marketing: yeah . project manager: what do you think ? marketing: i think it 's a three . industrial designer: a three ? project manager: okay , so we have two , two , three . industrial designer: and why is that ? marketing: i personally think , because i d i do n't think i maybe it 's easy to use , it has to be easy to find right away . i i think if you have the button at the right , i do n't think you can find the option button that easy . user interface: yeah , but you do n't have t have to use the button on the right . you can touch it . marketing: you can touch it . user interface: yeah . you you can touch options . industrial designer: it said bo both the options . marketing: yeah , okay , but you have y then you have here s written option on here , the teletext button , user interface: yeah . marketing: right ? industrial designer: yeah . marketing: okay , then okay , good . then i think also two , yeah . user interface: you can touch options project manager: a two , okay , user interface: and it 's comes out . project manager: because we have to industrial designer: a two , a two . marketing: yep . user interface: the uh the um below . project manager: it 's the box below it , industrial designer: uh the next question the next question . project manager: huh ? industrial designer: oh my god . marketing: user interface: project manager: otherwise we have two results in one question . user interface: it 's different . industrial designer: project manager: okay , next question . marketing: it 's easy to use , as well for younger as elderl elderly people . user interface: for young people i think it 's easy to use . project manager: marketing: young means sixteen to forty years . industrial designer: yeah , i was uh user interface: yeah . marketing: and elderly from forty eight to their death . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: i think it 's industrial designer: i think it 's the most useful uh remote control ever to be manufactured . user interface: in the entire mankind . project manager: okay , you 're very enthusiastic about your own design , marketing: also if you 're sixty years old project manager: huh ? industrial designer: yeah , but because it has the regular uh controls , li uh as you can see in the screen now , and uh you do n't have all the other options uh always uh on your screen . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: so it 's t i think it 's really easy to use . you want these options to marketing: also project manager: as well for the for the older people ? industrial designer: uh sure . marketing: yeah , as well as your if you 're fif sixty years old , you 're holding one of those things in your hand user interface: yeah , but uh yeah , but they they do n't want the uh extra options , right ? marketing: no , but we 're going to th make this f for a all kind of people , user interface: so project manager: and would it be easy for them to use the speech recognition ? user interface: yeah , okay , marketing: so it it it has to be user interface: but so they could uh i think it is . if they read a manual . project manager: because that might marketing: if you read the manual , user interface: yeah , alright . industrial designer: perhaps that is one of the most uh marketing: always . project manager: m maybe that 's the most user friendly and easy to use . user interface: because it it 's not it 's not it 's it 's not uh difficult . industrial designer: uh because a lot of user interface: you say you say uh record to to the to the speech recognition , industrial designer: channel one , channel four , yeah . user interface: then you say the question and the answer . and that 's everything it does , the speech recognition . industrial designer: project manager: yeah , well maybe that would make it even more easy to use for them . user interface: yeah . i think it would make it uh industrial designer: yeah , i think it does . marketing: so industrial designer: because all the people who ca n't uh user interface: i would make it two . marketing: also two ? user interface: yeah . industrial designer: uh a two . sure , two . marketing: not a seven for this ? user interface: three ? industrial designer: oh . project manager: i 'd say three . marketing: i would also say three . industrial designer: project manager: okay , so we have three three two two user interface: oh . you ? project manager: or industrial designer: two . user interface: oh . project manager: so what are we going to do ? user interface: well two and a half . project manager: okay , a three , i see . uh user interface: three ? no . industrial designer: give me more . marketing: project manager: another question . marketing: remotes overwhelmed with buttons . user interface: no . industrial designer: no . project manager: no . marketing: no , that that 's that 's user interface: but um i mean , marketing: yeah . user interface: that 's definitely one . marketing: tha that 's a one , i think , that 's definitely a one . industrial designer: that 's definitely our uh user interface: oh nee , oh seven is it ? it is . marketing: no ? user interface: yeah , uh marketing: oh yeah . project manager: yeah . yeah , user interface: the remote score . industrial designer: a false , yeah . project manager: but i think you should make it one scale with with one being good and seven being bad , marketing: yeah , i think is n't , this has to be something like is n't overwhelmed . project manager: because otherwise we ca n't uh calculate anything from the results , user interface: it 's not overwhelmed . yeah . project manager: so industrial designer: yeah , indeed . marketing: true . project manager: okay , a one , user interface: yep . project manager: because we designed for that , huh ? marketing: remote control has uh colours that different that meet different target groups . user interface: yes . industrial designer: user interface: 'cause we make them in different colours , project manager: yeah . user interface: so that they uh industrial designer: yeah , marketing: yeah . industrial designer: is optional . project manager: yeah , and i though w we had about single colours , marketing: that 's true . project manager: but you can also make uh a wood colour , not just one single colour but a wood-like thing , user interface: yeah . that it that it looks like wood , like something , yeah . industrial designer: huh . project manager: ca n't you ? marketing: also with rubber ? user interface: uh i think you can . project manager: whether it looks like wood , it is n't w it is n't wood marketing: yeah , okay . project manager: but user interface: it it feels like rubber , project manager: you can make a print on rubber , user interface: but project manager: ca n't you ? yeah . industrial designer: yeah . project manager: so that 's a one then , user interface: well but then when you scratch it it does come off . marketing: yeah ? project manager: huh ? marketing: that 's a one ? user interface: so that 's a bit industrial designer: yeah , it is it is harder to marketing: okay . project manager: do you have many questions ? marketing: uh i have industrial designer: to like project manager: oh , okay well marketing: user interface: oh we have time . industrial designer: geez . project manager: yeah , but we have we also we have to get to the money . industrial designer: we 're getting paid . we 're getting paid . marketing: the material used is spongy , user interface: what ? marketing: that that 's uh that 's a one , that 's m rubber . project manager: what spongy . user interface: yeah , yeah , it 's very spongy . industrial designer: uh . marketing: yeah , user interface: oh marketing: i th think it 's not the most spongy thing . user interface: but not it 's not very spongy , because it 's hard rubber . i think it 's a three . industrial designer: yeah , it 's a three , project manager: uh-huh , yeah . marketing: yeah . industrial designer: because you want to make it uh rather flexible but not too flexible , user interface: hard but yeah . you can break it . industrial designer: because it has a lcd screen . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: hard to lose , marketing: remote control is hard to lose . industrial designer: yeah it sh and it 's easy to find . user interface: y yeah , you could you could call it . marketing: y you ca n't you ca n't lose it if you 're sixty years old . if first time see the thing you didn did n't adjust uh set the microphone , and then you lose it , then you have lost it . user interface: yeah , y you can lose it , but it is n't hard to lose . marketing: it is n't hard , no . i think i think this is a two , personally . user interface: two . that it 's hard to lose ? marketing: no . user interface: yeah , it it is there 's the project manager: yeah , industrial designer: is n't hard to lose . project manager: so is n't hard to lose you . user interface: it 's a six , you think ? industrial designer: is n't hard to lose , yeah . marketing: is n't hard to lose . user interface: so it 's a two . yeah , you can lose it , so i do n't marketing: yeah . you ca n't lose it . user interface: you can make it a three i it does have an a built in function . marketing: or if you 're you 're sixty years old , your demands project manager: yeah , but a har a hard to lose is good . so it should this question should be hard to lose . it 's difficult to lose it . user interface: nee . hard to lose . oh right . industrial designer: yeah , this this is hard to lose . project manager: user interface: it is hard to lose . yeah , so then this is it is almost true , industrial designer: this project manager: a two . marketing: i think yeah , i think also . user interface: so a two . project manager: a two . industrial designer: two , yeah . project manager: okay . user interface: industrial designer: and most all because of the option to whoa . marketing: huh ? user interface: ooh . project manager: yeah , it 's okay . that happens above also . but maybe when you scroll away and back it will be normal , user interface: oh . industrial designer: uh . marketing: yeah ? oh , okay . project manager: but yep . oh , marketing: no . project manager: it is n't , user interface: oh well , project manager: well okay . user interface: it does n't . industrial designer: put the cor cursor on the . project manager: remember . marketing: okay okay okay . industrial designer: click . marketing: remote control mainly be sold to younger people . user interface: i think it will , industrial designer: true . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: true . marketing: yeah ? true ? very true ? user interface: uh well industrial designer: uh yeah . uh project manager: there . user interface: i a marketing: no , i do n't think very true because the colours . user interface: a two . marketing: we have the colours . um we have the buttons is are n't that that much . industrial designer: materials , yeah . marketing: nah , the material is n't that user interface: it 's it 's much more younger . industrial designer: uh okay . so ma uh make it make it a two . marketing: so i don i think i think it 's a three . project manager: well i think it 's it 's uh a lower number , so better because w we designed it for young people especially , user interface: yeah . marketing: yeah , project manager: did n't we ? user interface: i think it 's a two marketing: but i uh user interface: but marketing: okay , okay . project manager: what do you think ? marketing: i think because project manager: questions ? industrial designer: a two ? i think it 's two . i think it 's two too , two too too . project manager: two . uh-huh . marketing: yeah ? user interface: two two two . let 's make everything a two . marketing: in the features ? project manager: dissatisfy younger people . um user interface: younger people . it has industrial designer: well perhaps not . user interface: what did marketing: because younger peoples are cr critical and they wanted a lot of features on this thing . user interface: yeah . well that it does n't . industrial designer: well , n not exactly but uh uh if it had some games on it or something like that , user interface: yeah bu but industrial designer: but it 's for a remote control i think it i it would satisfy those needs . user interface: i think they like the speech . you could call to your uh industrial designer: yeah , the speech possibility , user interface: yeah , and the screen , industrial designer: the colours . marketing: lcd screen and scroll . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: scroll options , yeah . marketing: i i think they 'll be quite met with their expectations . project manager: yeah , but those are more fancy functions , not not really many features or something . user interface: right , that that that marketing: no . project manager: it has relatively few features , user interface: those are features . marketing: it 's three features , basically , project manager: with marketing: the lcd touch screen is feature . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: no , marketing: the microphone is a feature . user interface: are n't the features the microphone 's feature and that you can change the channel 's feature , and that you can change the volume is feature , project manager: yeah . user interface: and that you can change the options of the remote , uh uh something like that . yeah . project manager: ours had other features with marketing: yeah , okay . i think yeah , and then you have the audio settings , channel setting , video settings . industrial designer: the easy volume up button . user interface: those are features . industrial designer: remote younger people usually use the remote control to put on the volume . turn uh turn up the volume . marketing: yeah yeah . user interface: enough features ? marketing: so i 've chos i shou i think it 's it 's it 's a one . personally , yeah . i think once you 've 'cause you have the channel features b uh you have the uh screen features , audio features , the you have all buttons on it which you 'd like , microphone extra , lcd screen extra , scroll thing extra . project manager: okay , you think one , user interface: yeah . project manager: what do you think ? user interface: i think two or three . project manager: you . three , yeah . industrial designer: two . project manager: i 'd say three , so two it is then user interface: yeah . yeah uh a two a two . just another two . marketing: make it make it a two . project manager: or industrial designer: one two three . marketing: or make it uh a fucking two . user interface: we like two . industrial designer: right . marketing: you can see the remote control is r_ and r_ . user interface: yeah , there 's r_ and r_ in front . project manager: yeah . industrial designer: uh . project manager: yep . marketing: has user interface: uh it 's not the colour , so maybe you should make two , but it has r_ and r_ . marketing: oh yeah , do did have nah y you have the black one . user interface: yeah . marketing: and we 'll probably make also a yellow one . project manager: yeah . user interface: yeah , project manager: yeah , user interface: but not r_ and r_ yellow i think . project manager: maybe maybe two . well m th but the logo is on on the front , industrial designer: okay , true , yeah . marketing: maybe two . project manager: so a two , yeah , user interface: one d on i it 's the colours and the marketing: x_ marks spot . project manager: that 's marketing: and the menu is avail that is available is easy to use . user interface: i think it is , but i do n't know what you think . industrial designer: i think it 's easier to use than a regular remote control , because when you push on the options menu , you get the the the various options uh entirely explained . entirely explained . marketing: yeah , tha that 's so true . mm-hmm . project manager: user interface: industrial designer: instead of uh just finding out what an icon means on a button . marketing: mm-hmm . yeah , uh user interface: and you can navigate easier , because wi with the you have to push the the the arrows and with a normal tv uh remote . industrial designer: yeah , you can navigate . uh . marketing: i think that wou that would be quite hard to learn to use it . industrial designer: you 're not satisfied , okay . let 's start over again then . marketing: no , i 'm not not convinc . user interface: yeah . let 's make a different remote . well industrial designer: marketing: let 's go th for inhalation of air ] user interface: menu . industrial designer: marketing: i think it would be a t yeah , two . user interface: a two ? industrial designer: a two . marketing: now lower . project manager: oh , well that 's that 's pretty good , user interface: we only have twos . project manager: huh ? industrial designer: oh yeah , i think so . yeah . user interface: uh just twos . one three and a few ones . industrial designer: and three . marketing: so okay , we have one three , a one , that that have to got up . user interface: two threes . marketing: two two two two two . user interface: we m mostly have twos , so it 's pretty good . marketing: so two , yeah . the average is a two . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: the average . marketing: that is quite good user interface: yeah . i think so too . industrial designer: yeah , i think so . marketing: in my opinion . that user interface: we can be happy . marketing: ooh . industrial designer: save . user interface: yeah . marketing: ooh . user interface: what is it ? it 's like a bug or something . industrial designer: it 's a fly . user interface: a fly , yeah . industrial designer: oh m user interface: a f butterfly . marketing: top . user interface: yeah . that 's it . marketing: okay . project manager: that was your evaluation uh show , marketing: yes . project manager: okay , so we do n't have to calculate anything because of um these results . user interface: sure . marketing: no , it 's two . the average is two . project manager: okay , good . user interface: it 's good . yeah . project manager: um let 's see oh , it is n't asked to save but it did already industrial designer: yeah . exactly . marketing: yeah , i uh uh i uh saved it . project manager: and this everything okay . well , the next part uh might be a little bit difficult to do in a group , but i am willing to try it . marketing: project manager: because we are going to look at the finance and i have a nice excel sheet to do that . user interface: yeah . marketing: user interface: redesign . no . project manager: and um i 'm not sure if i put it in the project folder . industrial designer: project manager: look on that . um and we 're going to calculate the production costs , and if they are uh under or at twelve euro fifty , user interface: yeah . project manager: we 're good , and if they 're not we 're going to uh re-design , user interface: yeah . project manager: but we have to do that uh very very quick i think , user interface: so we 're going to erase features or something . project manager: yes . um i do n't know if i user interface: do you have the cost project manager: put the excel sheet in the user interface: or uh let 's hope . project manager: n not in the industrial designer: marketing: f fifty five euros . project manager: folder . i think it 's user interface: we 're going to be here at eight o'clock . project manager: i think it 's still in my own documents folder . industrial designer: user interface: we 're goin still going to be here at eight o'clock . industrial designer: marketing: no . project manager: oh shit . user interface: i doubt it . perhaps we 've got features that do n't exist in the excel sheet . marketing: yeah mm yeah , maybe . project manager: so user interface: no , marketing: the microphone . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: it was in my uh my information , so uh industrial designer: it i it was n't too much . marketing: yeah ? user interface: yeah . marketing: maybe you 're going scrap scrap it . industrial designer: as well as the lcd screen . whoa . project manager: okay , well this is it . user interface: well , if it does n't work project manager: um maybe i could ask one of you to uh fill it in , so that i can also uh take minutes , user interface: i want to fill it in , but uh project manager: and uh maybe the other can uh use that thing to count uh numerous functions . marketing: no prob . ah . user interface: but you should uh direct marketing: count it ? li like write it be project manager: well we have to count some things and we have to think about some things . but you have to fill in this column , huh ? industrial designer: count it . you got excel to count . user interface: the number of marketing: project manager: no , uh count uh number of functions , because for every button you have to pay industrial designer: oh okay . project manager: and there are different screen shots , so or different different screens , industrial designer: well i dra marketing: ah , okay , cool . industrial designer: uh danny , danny , i 'll do that , marketing: huh ? yeah ? oh , yea yeah , you design it . um industrial designer: because i draw the uh project manager: so user interface: we 've got a battery , one or t two batteries , or not ? nee one battery , with two small batteries . marketing: yeah . project manager: yeah , but it 's it 's more about the energy source , huh ? do you use a hand dynamo , a battery , kinetic or solar cells ? user interface: yeah . i would do a battery we do . right ? marketing: solar cell . no project manager: we 'll wait . user interface: a battery . one battery , industrial designer: no , no solar cell , no no no no . marketing: it took a battery ? user interface: right ? project manager: yeah . industrial designer: no hand dynamo . marketing: yeah . user interface: electronics , simple chip industrial designer: hand marketing: we have user interface: advanced chip , right ? marketing: no , we have sample speaker . industrial designer: on advanced chip . marketing: but b al but we also have sample speaker , do user interface: yeah , industrial designer: yeah , yeah . user interface: so this one and this one . uh we ha we have um single marketing: oh , we already on nine . user interface: what ? are we ? oh yay . marketing: we have double curved . user interface: the single . industrial designer: single nee single curved . double curved was uh uh see uh ju three dimensional . marketing: single . industrial designer: but it is n't three dimensional , user interface: oh the the industrial designer: it is n't curved in a l marketing: this one is user interface: it 's not going to work uh people . we have rubber . marketing: this one is curved like this , project manager: i 'll just fill it in . marketing: right . it 's curved like this . industrial designer: no no no , project manager: um rubber indeed ? industrial designer: single curved is like this . uh that 's the only curve you made , marketing: yeah , bu what industrial designer: not th uh curved like that . that 's uh marketing: oh , but we have curves like it and it . user interface: thirteen ? marketing: there are two curves , right ? oh , okay i understand , i understand . user interface: with a scroll wheel , industrial designer: huh ? user interface: right ? is he integrated ? industrial designer: yeah . marketing: rubber . user interface: no , eh ? i do n't know . industrial designer: yeah , marketing: push button . no , we do n't have push button . industrial designer: we got ta integrate scroll wheel and push button , because when you push it and you w it wo n't just pu uh makes possible to s user interface: oh yeah , right , we want it to it 's not it 's not no . industrial designer: not going to work ? marketing: lcd display . user interface: yep . industrial designer: okay . okay um user interface: fifteen , oh , too bad . oh but with special colour we have . a special form , right ? industrial designer: but now button supplements . we do n't got the button supplements . user interface: oh , we do n't have any buttons , so marketing: eighteen and a half , user interface: yeah , we need to uh marketing: damn . industrial designer: damn . marketing: we have to lower it with six points . user interface: no , uh we have fifteen and industrial designer: okay . marketing: twelve and half . user interface: oh , right . industrial designer: user interface: we could lose the curve . industrial designer: nah . marketing: we could use user interface: yeah , i would lose the curve . industrial designer: we could lose the scroll wheel . you could make it just a regular scroll wheel . user interface: but you ca n't push it , so you have to tap . industrial designer: yeah , if you ca n't push it you have to tap the the options window uh button here and then uh scroll down with the d with uh with uh the button . user interface: yeah , alright . project manager: yeah , i think that will be our best bet . user interface: so normal scroll wheel ? industrial designer: normal scroll wheel . user interface: and i think we should lose the curve . marketing: i think we should scrap the sample speaker . industrial designer: lose marketing: it 's four pri it four units . user interface: yeah , but if you would i it is a new feature , it it 's something special . industrial designer: okay , so we do n't exactly need the single we do n't need a curve . marketing: but w d wha user interface: no , the curve does n't really industrial designer: 's possible to lose curve . marketing: curved then it will be square . user interface: no , then it will wo n't uh stand up from the table . then it would just industrial designer: okay . marketing: was that does that mean to it , single curve ? industrial designer: yeah , that 's meant with scr uh with s curve . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: the curve is uh in a dimension . marketing: okay . industrial designer: if you make it a flat one , s n it 's no curve , you got no curves . user interface: so we would lose this one ? industrial designer: yeah , okay . marketing: yeah , but tha that that only is one . user interface: yeah , we could s yeah , a bit . industrial designer: no , two . marketing: no , one . user interface: sixteen point three . industrial designer: oh , okay , indeed . marketing: so we do n't user interface: so we still marketing: yeah , we also have to industrial designer: is it possible to make user interface: could could we do it on a regular chip on print or something ? marketing: no , otherwise we do n't have an lcd screen . user interface: no ? ma y you just ca n't do that , or uh industrial designer: no . project manager: and what did you change ? you changed the uh scroll wheel user interface: we changed th project manager: and user interface: yeah , and the single curved to uncurved . marketing: single curved . project manager: oh , but it 's just one marketing: flat . yeah , so that does does n't does n't that mu i think project manager: point , so maybe you should should uh user interface: no . marketing: scrap sample speaker ? project manager: yeah , you should you should drop the speech recognition . industrial designer: the sample speaker is two d wait , f s four points . marketing: that that 's uh user interface: yeah , but it 's t marketing: yes , four points . project manager: and then you can keep the curve . user interface: yeah , but it is uh it it is a new feature , project manager: or ca n't you ? user interface: it is something special . industrial designer: yeah , uh becau uh when you lose the marketing: yeah , but what what else what else uh do you want to scrap ? user interface: i do n't know . industrial designer: marketing: f you have to we have to scrap four points . user interface: yeah , that 's difficult . industrial designer: yeah . project manager: or make it on a hand dynamo , but i do n't think that will work . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: marketing: ma make it with wood instead of rubber ? industrial designer: no , that 's no . user interface: uh . industrial designer: make it w uh when you made it uh uh uh a remote control of wood ? user interface: we could make it titanium instead of rubber . industrial designer: you do n't make a remote control of ah . marketing: yeah , project manager: yeah , marketing: it it i project manager: mm-hmm . marketing: yeah , it also uh it also takes one point less . project manager: yeah , but uh a wooden remote control only helps for uh old people we discussed , user interface: oh . oh can i ask something ? project manager: yes ? user interface: what is special colour ? marketing: yeah . user interface: is that the wood uh wood uh marketing: i think it is . user interface: this , we have to have that one too ? industrial designer: it is n't . project manager: yeah , industrial designer: what ? marketing: yeah . project manager: but it 's only a half . but i think the only option is to drop the uh sample speaker . marketing: yeah . sample speaker . industrial designer: to knock the sample speaker , yeah . and sample sensor . user interface: th then we still have too much marketing: yeah , okay , user interface: if we use the uh industrial designer: but m yeah , course , marketing: three . point three . industrial designer: but user interface: yeah , we we scrap that one ? industrial designer: what we 'll have . marketing: huh ? industrial designer: let 's make it thirteen or fourteen . user interface: see , a po marketing: point twelve . user interface: three . we need point three . marketing: that 's a scroll wheel . user interface: uh it 's a colour . do n't make it wood . industrial designer: a colour . marketing: yeah , but a wood user interface: make it uh marketing: we can make it brown , dark brown , not wood . user interface: yeah , but it 's it 's special colour , is it a all kind of colours ? industrial designer: yeah , special colours , fruity colours . user interface: it 's also green or uh marketing: is it also industrial designer: yeah . marketing: no that that 's just normal colour fruit colours . user interface: yeah , but it 's a special colour than just rubber colour . marketing: normal colours , yellow user interface: you have to add something to the rubber to make it green . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: you do n't say here 's green rubber . industrial designer: they do n't sell green rubber plants . marketing: yeah , but then i d i do n't think we can ever make to a twelve and half . industrial designer: alright . user interface: yeah , you can , you should you have to lose marketing: but then we have to scrap lcd display , we have to scrap uh user interface: no , it is the scroll wheel , i guess . industrial designer: no no no . marketing: s advanced chip . no then we have to scrap everything we got because how many colours we gon na make ? industrial designer: if we lose the scroll wheel and make it totally uh depending uh dependent on uh the touch screen marketing: five ? then we have two . user interface: a push , marketing: s user interface: yeah . marketing: touch . industrial designer: then it 's possible to make . and then you can and then you can add to the colours . marketing: then we can make add two colours on it . yeah , two colours it . industrial designer: special c user interface: switch colours . industrial designer: okay , if you lose uh if you lose the user interface: it was such a great idea . industrial designer: you lose this one , you got eleven point five marketing: they can add two colours . industrial designer: and you make i and then you can make uh the spec single curve , for example . marketing: but the colours . um how ma uh the colours like l she told , is that all the colours we add or industrial designer: how d uh uh how many colours ? user interface: what do you mean ? industrial designer: special colours , all the colours you want , because you want to make p marketing: yeah , but we we we are we have yellow , red , uh black , titanium . industrial designer: yeah , but uh when you use more than one colour , it 's a special colour . user interface: oh . marketing: ah okay . user interface: but i think when you use the colour that 's not originally the rubber then you use special colour , industrial designer: i suppose . user interface: 'cause you have to add it . industrial designer: yeah . marketing: yeah , but the rubbers alls original black . user interface: yeah , so you always lose the special colour . you co you could make it always black , like normal remote . marketing: yeah b yeah , but we 're gon na make it yellow uh red , and then you add you have two special colours on top of the one we have now . industrial designer: nee we we also want to make ano another colour . user interface: oh right , yeah . yeah , we should u marketing: yeah , but m user interface: yeah . we have to make this like four or five or something . marketing: yeah , user interface: that 's what it means . marketing: because we have more colours than only black . project manager: yeah , but is n't it per remote that you pay ? user interface: yeah . marketing: i then i think i p i don i do n't think they me mean they 're special project manager: half ? user interface: oh right , yeah . is it per remote ? project manager: i think you pay half per remote . user interface: yeah . yeah , that 's right , project manager: so each remote with a special colour . user interface: and you one colour per remote . industrial designer: yeah , indeed , yeah . user interface: so then it is one . industrial designer: you do n't need four of those uh four of those special colours in one in one remote . marketing: yeah , okay okay , true . true , true . user interface: no . project manager: i hope . marketing: we have two points spare . project manager: so the battery , marketing: nee one point . project manager: we have um advanced chip on print . user interface: one . so it would be curved , single curve . industrial designer: project manager: because of thing user interface: or not ? project manager: yeah , well you can at least make it curved again . industrial designer: hmm . user interface: so y you just ca n't make a nice remote . industrial designer: yeah , single curve . project manager: because that was very important , user interface: it 's too bad for the speaker . project manager: huh ? so it 's curved , it 's still that so we we dropped the speech recognition together with the speaker . user interface: should we change that tha that that 's a one if not , marketing: mm yep . project manager: we dropped the scroll wheel . user interface: or not ? could you copy it ? project manager: and the rest is the same , user interface: and make it uh project manager: huh ? am i right ? marketing: y yea the scroll wheel is dropped . project manager: yes . user interface: the entire uh industrial designer: uh . huh . marketing: yep . user interface: perhaps you can then copy page or so . ooh . no . oh you you made the entire could you industrial designer: okay . undo , undo . user interface: oh industrial designer: undo . user interface: not well . industrial designer: so , 'kay . user interface: would you ? industrial designer: twenty minutes ? user interface: by the perhaps you can save this one , and then copy or something . add it copy page . select all . project manager: no , but you c yeah . user interface: alright , something went wrong . marketing: tap . project manager: okay , but this this new remote we can afford . user interface: it does n't work . let 's forget . marketing: it should 've work . industrial designer: okay , so you had this list at start ? project manager: hmm ? no , i had n't . industrial designer: alright . when did you receive this list ? project manager: i just received it . industrial designer: ah okay . user interface: yeah . oh project manager: they do n't work so hard at the finance department . user interface: ignore that . well , so industrial designer: ah okay . i suppose this is a user interface: too bad . industrial designer: okay , so we lose the scroll wheel , user interface: yeah . the microphone . industrial designer: the s project manager: yeah , and that 's it . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: and the microphone . user interface: a and we changed something , i guess , or not ? we oh no . marketing: yep . industrial designer: okay . project manager: twelve euro fifty . um and did you try to make a new design , or what were you trying to do ? user interface: yeah , i tried to copy that one , but it did n't work . project manager: it did n't work . user interface: so we could fix it like tha that it 's like this . project manager: hmm . strange . user interface: you could select it all , but then you ca n't erase . industrial designer: strange . project manager: oh , you can arrange industrial designer: you can only re erase ? user interface: erase . industrial designer: oh . user interface: when you saw th li uh earlier when we selected it , w i could n't erase anything . industrial designer: uh , no . project manager: hmm , ca n't you then just say copy ? industrial designer: bling . project manager: new page . paste . yes . industrial designer: ah . project manager: select none . user interface: just tap somewhere . industrial designer: just up somewhere b uh besides it , marketing: just tap somewhere . industrial designer: right . project manager: okay , user interface: yeah . project manager: and now you can erase . user interface: i do n't think i can , but uh we can try . industrial designer: uh , we already try . project manager: well it should be possible . user interface: oh , yeah , project manager: oh no . user interface: no , ha-ha . project manager: well you can draw over it with white uh pen . marketing: no ? user interface: yeah , we tried it earlier . project manager: oh . user interface: it 's very much work . project manager: yeah . sorry . user interface: project manager: well but that 's also useful for the evaluation , because i think uh we have a prototype now marketing: evaluation drops . project manager: which we can afford and uh we only need to draw a little bit to get a good uh design . doodle . and i think we should then move on to the production evaluation because of the time . marketing: and erase the mic . user interface: yeah , goodbye mic . industrial designer: all i need is no mic . user interface: marketing: industrial designer: project manager: let 's see , we can save this now . user interface: oh , i already erased half of the line . industrial designer: bon chance project manager: and move back to here . user interface: too bad , oh . project manager: industrial designer: marketing: user interface: like this ? project manager: mm-hmm . user interface: still looks nice . project manager: and then all green . okay , well thank you . user interface: oh , that 's erase . marketing: looks like a ipod . project manager: oh , no . industrial designer: no , project manager: hey , but you can erase that . industrial designer: add user interface: yeah , that 's a bit weird . industrial designer: yeah . project manager: uh-oh . user interface: oh , now i 'm line . industrial designer: s difference between lines and text and the pen . user interface: yeah . project manager: right . marketing: oh . all i need is mic . project manager: and you ca n't erase this ? marketing: project manager: hmm , strange . user interface: no , project manager: okay , well uh user interface: it 's weird . industrial designer: marketing: project manager: just leave it at this and quickly save . marketing: station page . project manager: um and then we are going to the project or product evaluation . industrial designer: huh , looks fucking boring now . project manager: we just did our project evaluation . um well , i think i can sit for that since it 's almost my final slide . um what did you think about uh the process ? how satisfied are we ? industrial designer: deadlines were sometimes very short . user interface: yeah . project manager: mm-hmm . user interface: bu but stressful . you think , no , my presentation is n't ready . industrial designer: but project manager: yeah . industrial designer: and stressful . marketing: i think we it should be b it would be better if we worked a little bit together . user interface: yeah . project manager: yeah . marketing: now we worked through each other , project manager: and you could ask things . user interface: yeah , you had information i did n't have marketing: something he said user interface: and then uh marketing: yeah , and you had information i also had , user interface: oh right . industrial designer: yeah . marketing: so some some things i had in my presentation , they already told , industrial designer: yeah . project manager: and for me it sometimes was a surprise who was going to present what , huh ? user interface: yeah . marketing: so project manager: and uh user interface: yeah . marketing: so yeah , that i do n't think that is the best way to work at for such project . project manager: yeah . user interface: no . project manager: so you would say uh communicate during our individual uh work . industrial designer: marketing: yeah , no , or maybe session of five minutes together or something , and then work separate . industrial designer: yeah , project manager: yeah . industrial designer: but but why not work here together , for example ? user interface: yeah , you could industrial designer: why should we be separated from each other in those difference uh different rooms ? user interface: yeah . marketing: yeah . yeah . project manager: mm-hmm . well , probably to simulate the whole working uh process , user interface: i think so too . yeah , but then you can work together too industrial designer: yeah . project manager: huh , th you ca n't have a meeting uh for several weeks . user interface: when marketing: yeah m yeah , like she told . then you can work together too by mail or by , i dunno , chat , something , project manager: no . user interface: a chat would also be uh industrial designer: huh , oh right . marketing: but now we 're completely separated from each other . i do n't think that was the best way , but industrial designer: but the technology was uh fantastic . user interface: well , marketing: yeah , the technology 's okay . user interface: i i do n't really like the board , it does n't really work great . sometimes i think . industrial designer: work now ? marketing: yeah okay , but i don i do i think becau that 's because industrial designer: perhaps it is e user interface: it does work , but sometimes it does n't erase or it does n't uh industrial designer: yeah , perhaps it is easier to get one of those uh dig digital pens or so and to uh and lay it next to that keyboard over there . marketing: yeah . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: so you can draw uh see it over th on the screen . marketing: yeah , like the f like a plotters or something , user interface: yeah . industrial designer: yeah . marketing: yeah . yep yep yep yep yep . project manager: so you do n't think the smartboard is is really useful user interface: but project manager: or user interface: well industrial designer: it 's useful , but not m user interface: it is useful , marketing: yeah , it is useful , but user interface: but it does n't really work all the time . marketing: no . user interface: th the pen does n't industrial designer: because when you put this pen on the screen uh uh for exam and line is d being drawn at at two or three centimetres uh below . user interface: the line is a bit off . project manager: yeah , so it 's maybe a bit unnatural also . user interface: yeah , industrial designer: alright . marketing: yep . user interface: you can point to where you want the line to be . but industrial designer: the project uh because of the deadlines you did n't had the time to uh have , you did n't have time to uh to make a very uh qualitati qualitative uh presentation . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: so you used uh this uh the different powerpoint presentations uh in which you put your uh material in the oh . user interface: project manager: that was n't me . uh so um user interface: yeah . industrial designer: was n't me . project manager: the means , we discussed the smart board , and what about uh this digital pen ? user interface: i i i used it , marketing: i did n't use it at all . user interface: it it was you can use it , it 's quite handy i think . project manager: yeah , well industrial designer: but i did n't i uh project manager: i use it as a a normal pen and and and only you use it to uh get it on the computer , user interface: yeah , i used it to y to project manager: huh ? user interface: yeah , it did work pretty well . industrial designer: i used it too , but oh well . user interface: i do n't think why you would want to use it actually , industrial designer: yeah . marketing: i did n't use . industrial designer: yeah , user interface: but it it does work . industrial designer: because it shou marketing: no yeah . project manager: yeah . industrial designer: to make some designs , marketing: it is it is industrial designer: it is very easy . marketing: yeah , it is easy for to design something and then load it in your computer . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: yeah , and then you can show it to everybody . industrial designer: but to write it th yeah . marketing: yeah . user interface: it does n't really write normally . marketing: yeah . it 's b bi little bit too big to write . user interface: it 's a bit industrial designer: yeah , it 's too big , it 's too fat . user interface: yeah . marketing: yeah . project manager: yeah . marketing: fat document , those . industrial designer: project manager: okay , um and what about the teamwork ? user interface: i think it was great , marketing: team work was okay . project manager: yeah , well i think so too . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: yeah . project manager: we marketing: only thing that we worked through , past each other . project manager: yeah , industrial designer: right . project manager: but that was it was our assignment , marketing: with some things that was only problem , user interface: yeah , but it was because we did n't uh marketing: but project manager: huh ? user interface: yeah . marketing: yeah yeah yeah , project manager: okay , marketing: but furthermore better . project manager: and maybe i should walk out of the room when you discuss uh this point , the leadership . user interface: marketing: that 's user interface: i thought it was good , but uh yeah . industrial designer: yeah . marketing: yeah , no prob . ah . project manager: yeah well , okay . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: not too much , not too too too too . marketing: yeah . user interface: yeah . marketing: okay . project manager: and creativity ? well , when we look at this i 'd say we have been creative , user interface: industrial designer: project manager: huh ? but user interface: well . industrial designer: yeah , or the room for project manager: there was room for industrial designer: it was the idea to be creative , so user interface: yeah . industrial designer: you got some standard ideas in your head and this what came out . marketing: mm-hmm . user interface: and you get get stuff from the from the computer , industrial designer: yeah . user interface: but industrial designer: the information uh was sometimes uh a little bit too late marketing: little bit uh lo yeah . too late user interface: yeah . industrial designer: or marketing: it it it took a lot of time before you got your ema user interface: you just sit there for ten minutes . yeah , industrial designer: yeah . marketing: yeah . user interface: where is that email ? marketing: i played i think seven times solitaire something . user interface: project manager: you did ? well , user interface: oh industrial designer: project manager: i did n't have time for that . user interface: did you ? is it on there ? is it on there ? marketing: wha user interface: i did n't find the did n't look but uh project manager: at some times i sometimes i received like like five emails at at one moment , industrial designer: was searching and searching . marketing: oh right , user interface: i did n't look , marketing: it is there . user interface: but project manager: and then marketing: no , i i never got that . industrial designer: project manager: marketing: i always user interface: i got like one email after ten minutes or something . project manager: i even got spam . or something like that . marketing: n yeah . user interface: industrial designer: marketing: user interface: that 's what we said . marketing: so does this i think lik oh and information was a bit low i think , sometimes , user interface: and it not a lot uh marketing: in in in in the beginning i did n't understand what what to do . user interface: no , the first one . industrial designer: no , w i did n't know user interface: i did n't know uh marketing: yeah , like i with with the remote and i never new we have t we had to uh yeah made a made a rec a remote control . industrial designer: make a r user interface: nee . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: and i did n't know what to do for the first ten minutes before we got here , marketing: yeah , so user interface: so i went , right . industrial designer: yeah . no stepping on the table and then looking at the internet page . user interface: yeah . project manager: and i was working and working and work user interface: just looking at the screen and uh industrial designer: no . project manager: okay , well um marketing: so , yeah . project manager: but after all we can say uh we are satisfied , but it it could 've been uh better . marketing: yeah . project manager: when we get uh when we have we would have gotten uh more information . user interface: yeah , an industrial designer: yeah , marketing: mm-hmm . faster . industrial designer: more information about the costs . user interface: yeah , that will be handy . marketing: yeah . industrial designer: first of all i did n't think uh that we were able to make an lcd screen uh first point , user interface: yeah . industrial designer: but uh it was possible uh uh , yeah . marketing: yeah , it only costs four units . uh yeah . project manager: yeah . user interface: yea uh so tha actually you could make an lcd screen but no mic , or it could make mic but no lcd screen , when you look at that . project manager: yeah , that was a bit mean to put it in the end . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: yeah . project manager: and uh what were the other points to to improve this whole process ? marketing: user interface: uh , i dunno . marketing: um yeah . user interface: think that 's about it . marketing: nothing . user interface: hmm . marketing: i think we got it already . user interface: heavier um less heavy laptops . project manager: yeah , they 're pretty heavy . industrial designer: uh . faster laptop . marketing: yeah . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: uh . they were they were just fine . user interface: but that 's not really uh marketing: and furthermore the the the network was okay . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: uh . marketing: everything you loaded was also user interface: yeah , everything worked . marketing: av available there . industrial designer: right . project manager: and so more time uh w might have improved the the quality of work , marketing: so project manager: is what you say . industrial designer: yeah . project manager: okay . marketing: yeah . yeah , but that it 's now half past four half past three , so user interface: yeah , but it 's just the the off hours between that you will work alone . marketing: yeah , okay . yeah , okay . user interface: then it pops up pop up screen came . five minutes in the meeting . marketing: mm-hm . mm . user interface: no . industrial designer: mm . marketing: yeah . project manager: okay , so more time during the individual work phases . um okay well uh user interface: huh . project manager: i just got my warning for the last five minutes , so i 'll move on to i guess my last slide , user interface: you did ? well marketing: project manager: yes , which is the closing . well uh , we managed , but we did it very quickly . i do n't know if that 's the best way to when it is n't is it when it is too expensive to quickly re-arrange it and say , okay , this is it , user interface: oh , right . project manager: but we had to do it , user interface: well project manager: huh , because we have to have a design , and that is within the budget . and we evaluated . maybe we should re-evaluate uh the product , but we did that before , and we also evaluated the project . and i think uh everybody 's uh very happy . at least i am , with the results , user interface: project manager: so uh celebration , well , for the three of you , user interface: yeah . marketing: yeah . project manager: because uh i have to write the final report now . user interface: champagne . yeah . marketing: project manager: but uh well , thank you very much for your co-operation , marketing: project manager: and i had a very nice day so far . industrial designer: yeah , sure . marketing: no prob . industrial designer: oh thank you . marketing: mm-hmm . project manager: okay . user interface: do we get another email ? industrial designer: bling . you 're fired . project manager: um marketing: i think you do . user interface: i i think we have to fill in a questionnaire again , project manager: yeah i have t user interface: but project manager: i think we also have to go to our own rooms again , but um well user interface: we do ? industrial designer: mm . project manager: i at least . but maybe you can try uh to make a screen shot of this , so i can try to include it in the final report . user interface: yeah . uh th that that one ? industrial designer: you can not project manager: yeah , maybe . user interface: you can just industrial designer: you can save it . project manager: wants to , but at least this one . user interface: yeah , but it 's it is n't a picture or , well , is it ? project manager: i know , we should remove this , industrial designer: you s uh file save as the j_ peg j_ peg . project manager: but it wo n't h okay . and uh please put it in the project folder then , huh . marketing: can you find it as a j_ peg ? user interface: no , industrial designer: no . user interface: is n't possible . but you can make a screen shot , i think . project manager: okay , well i uh user interface: marketing: no . user interface: industrial designer: no . project manager: i hereby officially close the meeting and uh i hope to see you uh soon . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: okay . marketing: in uh industrial designer: in about five minutes . user interface: uh oh , project manager: well , user interface: export . project manager: i think we 'll be a bit a bit longer , industrial designer: ah . project manager: but okay . well , happy celebration , huh ? user interface: industrial designer: oh thank you . user interface: images . industrial designer: whoo-hoo . let 's let 's have party . marketing: celebra user interface: how big do you want the images ? marketing: or should n't i ? industrial designer: let 's have some fun . project manager: how big ? uh user interface: yeah . industrial designer: huh ? project manager: not too big . industrial designer: user interface: this one ? project manager: whatever you think is good . marketing: six hundred . no , industrial designer: no marketing: i yeah . industrial designer: that uh is one thousand twenty four . marketing: i think eight hundred six hundred is better . project manager: user interface: this one ? industrial designer: yeah . marketing: yeah . user interface: industrial designer: if it browse . marketing: nah , name . user interface: um industrial designer: desktop . marketing: user interface: well it is n't on the desktop . marketing: hey . industrial designer: mm ? marketing: industrial designer: i do not know . user interface: you can only save it in my documents . marketing: project manager: industrial designer: oh ? marketing: oh my god . industrial designer: yeah . user interface: oh . project manager: user interface: oh , alright . yeah . industrial designer: okay . user interface: yeah . industrial designer: project manager: user interface: yeah . three . marketing: ten . user interface: can we stay here ? industrial designer: marketing: yeah . user interface: marketing: ten . user interface: yeah . marketing: uh . user interface: yeah , alright . industrial designer: okay . user interface: why ca n't we stay here ? industrial designer: alright . marketing: user interface: yeah . marketing: celebration time , come on . industrial designer: oh . user interface: industrial designer: oh . user interface: marketing: peace out nigger . entree user interface: marketing: </s> [SEP]summarize the discussion on evaluation criteria of remote control .
based on the analysis of user requirements , the group evaluated remote control by answering questions on the questionnaire . the questions on the questionnaire were mainly about fancy design , innovation , simplicity , target people , shape , colour , material , function , logo , etc . the final average score for remote control design is two . marketing thought it was a quite good score .