I meant more damning the future consequences for the immediately right action. What do you see Grug the barbarian doing? Stabbing the guy who just risked death for him in the back, or letting him go to fight another day? I just really can't see chaotic good justifying long term good for short term evil. That's like... Killing an informer in a terrorist cell for coming clean. Sure he was a terrorist, but he just did what he could to help you. Even knowing he will go back to that group. Sure you prevent evil, but you need to consider the message of what you just did is. it's this: