Strengthen Your Local Journalists.
MN Senate Channel
MN House Channel
MN House Channel 2
Labor/Unions
Send Us A Video
About The UpTake
The UpTake Team
The UpTake (http://theuptake.org/2018/03/01/students-nightmare-fails-to-sway-mn-gop-on-gun-violence-prevention-bills/)
Students' "Nightmare" Fails To Sway MN GOP On Gun Violence Prevention Bills
By Michael McIntee | March 1, 2018
More on Gun Violence
Subscribe to Gun Violence
MN House Media Services
Eva Goldfarb, High School Student
Eva Goldfarb says she and her St. Louis Park High School classmates have all had the same disturbing dream. In it, a shooter targets their school, much like one did in Parkland, Florida, killing 17 students.
"I wanted to say 'gosh what a horrible nightmare,'" she told a packed hearing room at the Minnesota legislature, "but I realized it can't even be classified as a nightmare. Because even though it has monsters and terror, nightmares aren't real. This is all too real, and we know it too well, and we've known it for too long."
"You are legislators and it is your job to keep us safe from gun violence in our school."
Goldfarb was testifying in favor of one of two gun violence prevention bills that have languished in the Republican-controlled Public Safety Committee for more than a year. Chair Rep. Brian Johnson (R) granted a hearing on the bills after bill author Rep. Dave Pinto publicly asked him to do so last week on the House floor. One bill would expand background checks. The other would allow family or police to ask a court to take away guns from someone who exhibits "red flags" indicating they may use the guns for violence.
Gun Rights Groups Claim Gun Owners Don't Want Background Checks
Video above: St. Louis Park High School student Eva Goldfarb testifies
Video at bottom: Entire House Public Safety Committee hearing.
Testimony from Goldfarb and law enforcement officers in favor of the bills was countered by testimony from gun rights groups. Robert Doar of the Minnesota Gun Owners Caucus said the background checks were "unconstitutional" and a survey of his members show that 95% of gun owners oppose them. That runs counter to most surveys that show 90% of Americans support expanded background checks and among National Rifle Association members (NRA) 72% support expanded background checks.
"No background check can stop an evil mind," said Joseph Olsen with the Gun Owners Civil Rights Alliance.
Pinto said that no single policy change would prevent all gun violence deaths, but reasonable steps need to be taken.
The committee voted to table the bills, dimming the chances that they will reach the full House for a vote this session. Only one Republican, Rep. Keith Franke, voted with the Democrats to prevent the background check bill from being tabled.
Despite the vote, Pinto saw positive signs in today's hearing. "I heard general agreement that we should be taking steps to keep guns out of the hands of dangerous people." He thinks he heard a willingness to pass the bills this session.
Thank you to our legislative sponsors:
Support this story and all the stories from The Uptake. Donate.
Michael McIntee
Michael McIntee is a former network TV news executive with more than 30 years of broadcasting experience. He began his broadcasting career at the University of Minnesota's student radio station. He is an expert producer, writer, video editor who has a fondness for new technology but denies that he is a geek. More about Michael McIntee »
@https://twitter.com/mmcintee
MN House
Dave Pinto
Minneapolis Releases Body Cam Videos Of Police Killing Blevins
Body cam video of Minneapolis police shooting and killing Thurman Blevins has been released. Blevins was killed on June 23rd after police responded to a 911 call of a male firing a handgun.
Thousands of MN Students Protest Gun Violence
Crowd Chants After GOP Majority Refuses To Debate Gun Violence Prevention Bills In MN House
View all Gun Violence Posts →
Parents Testify Need for Kids to Return to School as Senate's Education Committee Launches First Meeting of 2021
Reporting from the Senate Committee on Education Finance and Policy which discussed "getting kids back to school."
Opinion: Two Americas
Column: Murdered by MPD: Dolal Idd
View all Minnesota Posts →
Simon Urges MN Legislature To Invest In Democracy
Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon says the state can do more to insure voting rights. He and legislative leaders unveil a plan to increase voting security; decrease barriers to voter registration; restore of voting rights for those who were formerly incarcerated; and protect voter privacy.
Reinvestment Urged in Program Providing Food to Underserved Minnesotans
13 Arrested Protesting Pre-Emption Bill In Rep. Garofalo's Office
View all MN House Posts →
MN GOP Reps Won't Promise A Hearing On Gun Bills
Two GOP committee chairs are put on the spot and asked if they will give bills aimed at reducing gun violence a hearing this session. Neither will commit to a hearing. The bills have been in their committees for about a year.
Why The NAACP Opposes MN Police Body Cam Bill
View all Brian Johnson Posts →
A Minnesota Republican majority refuses to allow debate on two gun violence prevention bills, effectively stopping them from advancing this session.
View all Dave Pinto Posts →
Where This Story Happens
By: L. Nur, Freelance Journalist While national and local pro-Trump mobs and protestors swarmed the D.C. and Minnesota Capitols yesterday, our state Senate began its 2021 legislative session's Education Finance and Policy Committee meeting. The meeting was held via Zoom and began at 3pm. (more…)
By McKenzie Kemper: Freelance Writer I am the whitest kid you will ever meet. It is a running joke among my friends that if the power goes out that you can use my legs as a flashlight to get around.
By Marjaan Sirdar, Freelance Columnist The UpTake is not responsible for the content in this column. Claim: In Black and brown communities, Minneapolis police continue to act without regard for human life or the Constitution as evident in the recent killing of 23-year-old Somali-American, Dolal Idd. (more…)
[largo_social_links]
Tweets by @UpTakeDC
The UpTake
Our Supporters & Sponsors
Categories Select Category Blog (50) Opinion (16) Site Notes (8) The UpTake (20) DC (889) Fact Check (13) Issues (2,092) African-American History (6) Arts (11) Campaign Finance (83) Criminal Justice (39) Democracy (7) Economy/Jobs (455) Education (150) Energy (30) Environment (234) Frac Sand Mining (5) FBI Actions (11) Free Speech (14) Gun Violence (65) Health Care (175) Homelessness (8) Housing (17) Immigration (98) Indian Affairs (48) American Indian Movement (3) Dakota Conflict 150th Commemoration (7) Infrastructure (6) Internet Access (3) Labor/Unions (324) Legislative Reporting (1) LGBT Issues (140) Marriage Equality (41) Media (75) Minimum Wage (35) Neighborhood Empowerment (9) Net Neutrality (38) Occupy Movement (136) Police/Community Relations (89) Political Comedy (12) Privacy (4) Racial Equality (84) Ranked Choice Voting (6) Sustaining Solutions (61) Northside Project (43) Tax Fairness (6) Torture (1) Transit (28) Vikings Stadium (4) Voter Suppression (150) War/Peace (198) Wildlife (1) Youth Issues (11) Live Coverage (390) MN Governor Debates Live (42) MN House Live (26) MN Senate Live (43) Quick on The UpTake (14) US House Live (3) US Senate Live (2) White House Live (48) MN Recount 2010 (80) Movement History (1) Netroots (89) Political Races (756) MN (530) 2010 Statewide (16) CD1 (28) CD2 (58) CD3 (32) CD4 (1) CD6 (31) CD7 (10) CD8 (35) Minneapolis Mayor's Race 2013 (28) Minneapolis Mayor's Race 2017 (6) MN Attorney General Race (1) MN Governor's Race (202) Secretary Of State (8) St. Paul Mayor's Race 2017 (4) US Senate 2008 (51) US Senate 2012 (2) US Senate Race 2014 (14) US Senate Races 2018 (10) MN Legislative Races (14) Party Propaganda (49) Presidential (165) 2008 (17) 2012 (33) 2016 Presidential Race (66) Bachmann (45) Mitt Romney (9) Newt Gingrich (2) Rick Santorum (1) Ron Paul (3) Security State (2) Security v. Citizens (4) Small Business Spotlight (1) States (3,508) Alabama (1) Alaska (4) Arizona (9) California (18) Colorado (58) Connecticut (3) Delaware (3) Florida (22) Hawaii (3) Idaho (2) Illinois (13) Indiana (2) Iowa (35) Kansas (1) Kentucky (3) Louisiana (16) Maine (1) Maryland (3) Massachusetts (12) Michigan (14) Minnesota (3,000) Minneapolis (77) MN House (279) MN Senate (253) St Paul (13) Mississippi (1) Missouri (4) Nevada (4) New Mexico (1) New York (19) North Carolina (8) North Dakota (6) Ohio (10) Oklahoma (1) Oregon (2) Pennsylvania (13) South Carolina (1) South Dakota (1) Tennessee (2) Texas (9) Utah (3) Vermont (2) Virginia (7) Washington (14) West Virginia (1) Wisconsin (266) Milwaukee (16) Wyoming (2) The Quilt: Policy, Art, and Healing (1) Today's UpTake (74) UpTake Leadership Profile (8) World (124) Afghanistan (9) Brazil (1) Canada (4) Cuba (3) Denmark (2) Egypt (12) England (2) Ethiopia (1) Ghana (1) Haiti (1) India (3) Indonesia (1) Iran (7) Iraq (11) Israel (20) Japan (3) Kenya (2) Liberia (1) Libya (15) North Korea (1) Pakistan (2) Palestine (20) Poland (1) Somalia (9) South Africa (1) South Korea (3) Spain (1) Syria (10) Zimbabwe (1) YouTube (1)
Archives Select Month January 2021 (5) December 2020 (4) November 2020 (7) October 2020 (14) September 2020 (2) August 2020 (5) July 2020 (15) June 2020 (5) May 2020 (12) April 2020 (5) March 2020 (4) February 2020 (5) December 2019 (2) November 2019 (8) August 2019 (2) July 2019 (2) June 2019 (3) May 2019 (1) April 2019 (2) February 2019 (1) January 2019 (3) December 2018 (3) November 2018 (1) October 2018 (3) September 2018 (5) August 2018 (11) July 2018 (6) June 2018 (3) May 2018 (7) April 2018 (4) March 2018 (13) February 2018 (9) January 2018 (2) December 2017 (11) November 2017 (7) October 2017 (4) September 2017 (10) August 2017 (13) July 2017 (12) June 2017 (17) May 2017 (18) April 2017 (14) March 2017 (20) February 2017 (17) January 2017 (39) December 2016 (30) November 2016 (23) October 2016 (21) September 2016 (16) August 2016 (28) July 2016 (19) June 2016 (14) May 2016 (16) April 2016 (22) March 2016 (28) February 2016 (11) January 2016 (14) December 2015 (20) November 2015 (20) October 2015 (16) September 2015 (8) August 2015 (10) July 2015 (14) June 2015 (11) May 2015 (23) April 2015 (22) March 2015 (19) February 2015 (23) January 2015 (21) December 2014 (10) November 2014 (19) October 2014 (31) September 2014 (14) August 2014 (15) July 2014 (1) June 2014 (2) May 2014 (2) April 2014 (6) March 2014 (7) February 2014 (8) January 2014 (8) December 2013 (9) November 2013 (19) October 2013 (15) September 2013 (11) August 2013 (15) July 2013 (12) June 2013 (7) May 2013 (17) April 2013 (11) March 2013 (11) February 2013 (19) January 2013 (17) December 2012 (9) November 2012 (32) October 2012 (35) September 2012 (25) August 2012 (40) July 2012 (16) June 2012 (33) May 2012 (63) April 2012 (66) March 2012 (79) February 2012 (92) January 2012 (49) December 2011 (38) November 2011 (34) October 2011 (36) September 2011 (17) August 2011 (34) July 2011 (58) June 2011 (73) May 2011 (117) April 2011 (95) March 2011 (158) February 2011 (164) January 2011 (90) December 2010 (116) November 2010 (110) October 2010 (114) September 2010 (97) August 2010 (131) July 2010 (130) June 2010 (75) May 2010 (102) April 2010 (71) March 2010 (64) February 2010 (30) January 2010 (43) December 2009 (121) November 2009 (56) October 2009 (88) September 2009 (49) August 2009 (58) July 2009 (90) June 2009 (58) May 2009 (104) April 2009 (84) March 2009 (40) February 2009 (33) January 2009 (43) December 2008 (71) November 2008 (111) October 2008 (137) September 2008 (95) August 2008 (136) July 2008 (62) June 2008 (127)
Harnessing community journalism for social and racial justice.
© Copyright 2021, The UpTake