 After Goldenvoice's Paul Tollett offered him a deal he and Klinghoffer recorded The Bicycle Thief's debut, joined on the album by Kevin Fitzgerald (Geraldine Fibbers).This was Klinghoffer's first recording experience and he contributed guitars, keyboards, and on some tracks the drums.Their only studio album is "You Come and Go Like a Pop Song", released in 1999, and re-released with modified track listing and artwork in 2001.