 His second album — Gypsyfingers — was covered by several notable media outlets, including Rolling Stone, Marie Claire, Fox News, Performing Songwriter, CMJ, among others.In 2004, he released a new album, Edible Darling on the Bardic record label, for which he received coverage in several respected magazines including Rolling Stone and CMJ

In 2008 Arthur released a new studio album entitled "Mouth Feel".The album features a duet with Rachael Yamagata entitled Sun Also Rises.