 However, by mid-December 2016, Garner's energetic performances managed to win over the Rangers fans and they adopted the song "Glad All Over" by band The Dave Clark Five as a tribute to him then launched a late campaign to make the song the Christmas number one, with it eventually reaching number 31.Garner started his third Old Firm match on Hogmanay 2016 but left the field after being injured in the buildup to Rangers' goal, being replaced by Martyn Waghorn after sixteen minutes.On 3 January 2017, it was reported he would be sidelined for one to three months with a dislocated shoulder, although later reports indicated Garner could return in early February 2017.