 The original and more controversial manuscript ending was not officially published, though is often included as an alternate ending in many current editions of the novel.In this version, Falkland argues in court that Caleb's agenda is merely revenge.Caleb responds, claiming himself to be a voice of justice and offering to gather witnesses against Falkland, but the magistrate suddenly silences him and denies his offer, calling Caleb insolent and his accusations ludicrous.