 On 4 August 2009, Championship club Coventry City signed McIndoe on a 2-year contract under manager Chris Coleman for an undisclosed fee believed to be around £325,000.He received his third international call up against Japan in Yokohama, but the winger pulled out of the squad due to a minor knee injury.McIndoe played in numerous positions throughout the season, scoring 1 goal and making 43 appearances for the Sky Blues.