 Her first starring role was in the 2003 revival of "" as June; she went on to play Caroline in the 2005 jukebox musical "Good Vibrations".Reinders played the role of Glinda in the 2005 Chicago production of "Wicked", alongside Ana Gasteyer as Elphaba; for this role, she received a Joseph Jefferson Award nomination for Best Actress in a Principal Role.She and Gasteyer finished their runs in the Chicago company on January 22, 2006.