 In 2002, West Hill was noted for beating rival R. H. King Academy 150 to 58 in a basketball game in which West Hill star Denham Brown scored 13 three pointers.From the 2009-10 school year, West Hill kept the "Warriors" moniker, but the Native American head, which was used since its inception, was replaced with a stylized Trojan mascot in 2010.West Hill Collegiate Institute was one of several Toronto high schools with low enrolment rates that were placed under Pupil Accommodation Review in 2015 by the Toronto school board.