 Jerome McGann describes in detail the editorial principles of Gabler in his article for the journal "Criticism", issue 27, 1985.In the wake of the controversy, still other commentators charged that Gabler's changes were motivated by a desire to secure a fresh copyright and another seventy-five years of royalties beyond a looming expiration date.In June 1988 John Kidd published "The Scandal of "Ulysses"" in "The New York Review of Books", charging that not only did Gabler's changes overturn Joyce's last revisions, but in another four hundred places Gabler failed to follow any manuscript whatever, making nonsense of his own premises.