 His impressive spell at Brighton resulted in the club wanting to sign Anyinsah on a permanent deal but the move never happened as several clubs, like Swindon Town and Carlisle United, were also chasing his signature.In January 2009, Anyinsah re-joined fellow League One side Carlisle United for an undisclosed fee.However, his move was revealed by the media and manager Greg Abbott criticised people for revealing the details of the club's transfer targets.