 After missing the first game of the 2013–14 season through an ankle knock, Craig was again an ever-present starter until he received a red card during a 0–0 draw with Carlisle United on 31 August 2013.After serving his suspension, Craig returned to the side and despite breaking two bones in his hand during a 2–1 victory over Gillingham on 24 January 2014, he saw out the game and played the subsequent matches with his hand in a cast.Craig held the captaincy for much of the season (in place of the injured Kevin O'Connor) and jointly lifted the League One runners-up trophy with O'Connor after the final game of the season against Stevenage on 3 May.