 The replay was much more conclusive as first-half goals by Jimmy Barrett and Billy Cogan were followed by two more Liam Goode and Séamus Coughlan goals in the second-half.The final score of 4–6 to 0–10 gave Murphy a first All-Ireland medal.Murphy added a second championship medal to his collection in 1974 as divisional side Carbery were defeated by 2–8 to 1–8.