 They had four children together, but no known grandchildren.Shumway moved to Albany, New York, where his first two sons were born in 1796 and 1798, relocated to Schenectady in around 1800, and returned to Albany in 1806.In 1820 he settled in Lyme; after he lost his farm there through a title defect a few years later he returned to Freehold, where he died in 1843.