 Sometime after 1970, the high school was moved to another location along Horseshoe Road, renamed Conestoga Valley High School, and built completely new while the old building was dedicated as Smoketown Elementary School.Located in Bird In Hand, Penn Johns Elementary School was the previous fifth elementary school of Conestoga Valley.It was the last remaining school for the Plain community that over time lost its original purpose and transitioned into a regular elementary school that served all local residents.