 Khalil as Winters has grown in popularity among viewers, who voted her onto "Top Actress" lists in publications such as "Soap Opera Digest", "Soaps In Depth" and "Soap Opera Update".Critics have also praised Khalil for her portrayal; "Soap Opera Digest" named her performer of the week during Lily's internet-predator storyline, citing the subtlety of her performance.Mark McGarry of "Soap Opera Weekly" named the actress outstanding performer of the week on February 28, 2005, praising Khalil's "remarkable range".