 On July 12, 1993 at the Noble County Courthouse, Dillon pleaded guilty to the five murders.Dillon was incarcerated at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility for five consecutive sentences of thirty years to life for aggravated murder.After an attempt by Dillon's wife to sell Dillon's story to Hollywood, Jean Paxton, Jamie Paxton's mother, and Ohio State Senator Bob Ney, passed the Paxton Bill, which barred killers or their relatives from profiting from their crimes.