 Worthington was played in a more attacking role at Halifax than he had been used to previously in his career, but he had great success including two goals against Abbey Hey in the FA Cup in a 6–0 victory.Worthington also bagged a goal from the edge of the box on Boxing Day 2012 against Gainsborough Trinity.In January 2013, Worthington suffered an injury against Solihull Moors after going in for a challenge which won The Shaymen a penalty.