 On 18 August 2007 he made his Football League debut, coming on as a substitute in the closing minutes away at Barnet.With the departure of Lionel Ainsworth, Gwynne was handed a chance in the first team and made 16 appearances in mid-season.Originally allowed to leave the club at the end of the 2009–10 season, he was eventually offered a new one-year deal to remain at Hereford.