 On January 31, Paynter scored his first, and only, NHL goal, against Daniel Berthiaume of the Minnesota North Stars in a 4–3 win.In 13 games with the Capitals, Paynter had a goal and three points.On May 5, Paynter played in his first career NHL playoff game, as he was held with no points, and 10 penalty minutes, in a 3–0 loss to the Boston Bruins.