 Appearing in the second All-Star Game held that summer, on July 30, 1962, at Wrigley Field, Herbert hurled three scoreless innings of relief and was credited with the victory when the AL broke a 1–1 deadlock and went on to a 9–4 triumph.It would be the Junior Circuit's last All-Star win until 1971.The following season, he led the American League in shutouts thrown, with seven.