 When the Big Coffin Hunters frame the young Gunslingers for murder he kills mayor Hart Thorin and plants the rook's skull that ties Cuthbert and by extension Roland and Alain to the crime.He was killed by Roland when the three young gunslingers attacked Eldred and his thirty men, who were riding to meet George Latigo.Clay Reynolds is Eldred Jonas' right-hand man and the quietest of the Big Coffin Hunters.