 In April 2012, "The Wall Street Journal" reported that in the five years since the 2007 "The New York Times" story, federal courts of appeals had cited Wikipedia about 95 times.The story also reported that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit vacated convictions in a cockfighting case because a juror used Wikipedia to research an element of the crime, expressing in its decision concerns about Wikipedia's reliability.In one notable case, the trademark of Formula One racing decision, the UK Intellectual Property Office considered both the reliability of Wikipedia, and its usefulness as a reliable source of evidence