 The "New York Daily Graphic" would later publish "the first reproduction of a photograph with a full tonal range in a newspaper" on March 4, 1880 (entitled "A Scene in Shantytown") with a crude halftone screen.The first truly successful commercial method was patented by Frederic Ives of Philadelphia in 1881.Although he found a way of breaking up the image into dots of varying sizes, he did not make use of a screen.