 In the fourth, the Yankees loaded the bases on three walks off of Nagy before Paul O'Neill hit a grand slam off of Chad Ogea that gave them a commanding 6–1 lead and silenced the Jacobs Field crowd.Rain was a constant throughout the game and the rain fell on the Indians' parade as the Yankees took a 2–1 series lead.Jacobs Field in Cleveland, Ohio
Game 4 proved memorable as two veteran starters, Dwight Gooden and Orel Hershiser, battled back and forth.