 They did, however, also criticize the instability on Windows 95, simplified magic system, and lack of scenario descriptions but overall rated the game as equal or more to its predecessor.A reviewer for "Next Generation" commented that typical war simulation fans would likely be turned off by the game's unhistorical setting, lighthearted atmosphere, and lack of challenge, but that its solid sense of fun would make it entertaining for those willing to try something different.Andy Butcher reviewed "Fantasy General" for "Arcane" magazine, rating it a 7 out of 10 overall.