 Upon retirement, Kay returned to the North West to settle back on Merseyside.A few months short of 40 years since his transfer from Sheffield Wednesday in 1962, Tony Kay was once again present on the pitch at Goodison Park among a group of 100 Everton Legends, as the club celebrated a record 100 seasons of top flight football at the start of the 2002–03 campaign.He received a standing ovation from the crowd.