 From the same opera, he recorded the ballad "When rocked on the billows".His other recordings of this period were Balfe's setting of Tennyson's "Come into the garden, Maud", "When a Pullet is Plump", from "Chu Chin Chow", "Song of the Bowl", from "My Lady Frayle", and, with Violet Essex, "Any time's kissing time", from "Chu Chin Chow".In 1923 he recorded four numbers from "Lilac Time" for Vocalion ("Dream Enthralling"; "I want to carve your name"; "The Golden Song"; and "Underneath the lilac bough") with Clara Butterworth and Percy Heming.