 She would return to the role in January 2018 for a 6-week run, including 2 weeks co-starring with friend and fellow musician Jason Mraz as Dr. Pomatter.Mraz had previously duetted with Bareilles on two songs featuring the Pomatter part on the "What's Inside" album.She returned to the role again in January 2019, for a 4-week run opposite Gavin Creel as Dr. Pomatter.