 During Villanova's Elite Eight matchup versus #1 seed Pittsburgh in the Tournament, Reynolds made a game-winning shot with 0.5 seconds to go to send Nova to the 2009 Final Four in Detroit.On April 21, 2009, Reynolds declared for the 2009 NBA draft, but did not hire an agent, he withdrew from the draft on 9 June 2009.On January 11, 2010, Reynolds scored a season-high 36 points, on 5-of-5 three-pointers, in a 92–84 win over Louisville.