 In March 2018, Garfield reprised the role of Prior when the "Angels in America" production transferred to Broadway for an 18-week limited engagement at the Neil Simon Theatre, alongside a majority of the London cast.Reviewing the production for "The Washington Post", Peter Marks commented that "nothing [Garfield's] done prepares you for the star-powered dexterity of his Prior" and considered his performance to be the "persuasive moral core of the piece".He won the Tony Award for Best Actor in a Play for his performance.