 Relics and mementoes of 1745 were preserved and Charles himself became celebrated in "increasingly emotional and sentimental language".The publication in the 1830s of parts of "The Lyon in Mourning" by Episcopalian bishop Robert Forbes (1708-1775), a collection of source material and interviews with Jacobite participants in the 1745 rising, reinforced this memorialising tendency.19th century historiography often presented the Scots Jacobites as driven by a romantic attachment to the House of Stuart, rather than as having a wide range of individual motivations.