sentences:  Beach, in his work "Apples of New York", noted that "several different varieties" had been propagated in America and England under the name 'Winter Pearmain' and that in many descriptions "it is impossible to determine which Winter Pearmain the writer had in mind".By contrast, Hogg believed the apple identified in some catalogues of the time as 'Old Pearmain' to in fact be a variety called 'Royal Pearmain'.Hogg later claimed to have identified the "true Old Pearmain" growing in the Dymock area.