sentences:  Nutter featured regularly during Aldershot's return to the highest tier of non-League football, making 28 appearances in all competitions and netting once in a 4–2 away victory over Bishop's Stortford in the FA Trophy in January 2004.Aldershot narrowly missed out on back-to-back promotions, losing on penalties in the play-off final to Shrewsbury Town.Although Nutter did not play in the final, he did feature in both legs of the semi-final as Aldershot defeated Hereford United on penalties.