Cytunwn fod angen diwygio'r system lloches ond nid dyma'r cynigion a fydd yn datrys ein heriau gyda'r tosturi a'r parch at hawliau dynol y mae'r DU fodern yn cael canmoliaeth amdano ledled y byd. Mae angen i ni weld cynigion sy'n galluogi Llywodraeth Cymru i weithredu polisi integreiddio effeithiol - ein cynllun Cenedl Noddfa - o'r diwrnod cyntaf. Mae hyn yn golygu bod angen rhoi ceiswyr lloches mewn cymunedau ac nid mewn canolfannau derbyn ynysig tebyg i garchardai. Mae angen i unigolion allu gweithio a defnyddio eu sgiliau wrth iddynt aros am ganlyniad eu cais. Yn anad dim, rhaid lleihau effeithiau'r system fudo ar blant a phobl sy'n agored i niwed - o effaith gwahanu teuluoedd, bod ar eu pen eu hunain, neu beidio â gallu cael gafael ar gyllid ar gyfer pobl ddiymgeledd.
We agree that the asylum system needs reform but these are not the proposals which will resolve our challenges with the compassion and respect for human rights which the modern UK is lauded for around the world. We need to see proposals which enable the Welsh Government to implement an effective integration policy – our Nation of Sanctuary plan – from day one of arrival. This means that asylum seekers need to be placed into communities and not in isolated prison-like reception centres. Individuals need to be able to work and use their skills whilst they await the outcome of their claim. And above all, the impacts of the migration system on children and vulnerable people – from the separation of families, the impact of being unaccompanied, or not being able to access destitution funding – must be minimised.