Update: Much better (previously: Works but smelly and temporarily stains clothing.)

Update: They sent me new bottles (and gave a refund!) and said they think there may have been a manufacturing error. The new bottles do indeed smell much better (quite nice and mild actually) and it's white and not yellowish. I used it once and it worked fine. So I agree probably we got a bad batch, but the new batch is good and customer service is great. (Note my comment about the clothing had to do with sunscreen that rubbed off onto clothing (neck area to be precise). I never apply sunscreen directly to clothing.) It worked and was accepted at the park we visited. However, it smells terrible and is very waxy. It is very difficult to wash off and when it touches clothing, it turns light colors yellow and dark colors white (but later washes out with detergent). We changed to a zinc oxide based reef safe sunscreen and it was much easier to work with.

###

