not good anymore

Application is easy. I find the material to be easy to apply, spread, and line my eye the way I like it. I use it on the lower water line and above my lashes for the top. I've been using this exact product for over 5 years, however, something must have changed like 18 months ago. The top line smears off all over my eyelid. I get black all over the crease of my eyelid. I will not reorder this specific eyeliner anymore.

###

