America's Test Kitchen got it wrong here

I bought this based on the ATK recommendation and the unavailability of their top option. I think they got it wrong for once. The scrubber pads only lasted 2 uses before the outer layer was fraying and coming off. Metal shavings were exposed making it no better than a normal metal bristle scrubber. The pad is also very loose in the holder and doesn't allow for scrubbing of caked on messes, it just rips more. The cleaner itself does even work that well on cast iron grates like those found on the Weber Genesis II and Spirit II. It was much more effective for cleaning my stainless grates on the upper platform on my grill. I would highly recommend against this product.

###

