Different Suppliers for Same Product but not the Same Quality

I order a 2-pack of sleeve protectors for my recipe cards. They sleeves were clear and thin and I liked them so much I clicked on "Buy it again" to order another 2-pack. They were not as clear and thin, nor were the exact same size (disappointing...). The first set was sold by Light Lifestyle and shipped by Amazon; the second set shows sold by Elton Orlando and shipped by Amazon. When I looked again I saw there is yet another shipper under the same listing. I'm afraid to try again.

###

