 Pari gbolohun ti o tẹle: Ni ọjọ 22 Oṣu Kini ọdun 2019 o royin pe Priestley sunmọ lati fowo si adehun pẹlu All Elite Wrestling AEW lẹhin ti o kọ adehun WWE kan. A kede rẹ ni atẹjade ti 27 Kínní 2019 ti Road To : Double Or Nothing ti Priestley yoo darapọ mọ ile-iṣẹ naa, ati pe yoo ṣe ifilọlẹ rẹ ni Fight for the Fallen ni ọjọ 13 Oṣu Keje ọdun 2019, nibi ti yoo ṣe ẹgbẹ pẹlu Shoko Nakajima lati ṣẹgun Britt Baker ati Riho, ati Priestley fa ariyanjiyan nigbati igbesẹ akọkọ rẹ ninu idije naa n fun Baker ni ikọlu lile si ẹhin ori rẹ, fifun Baker ni iṣọn-ẹjẹ ati fifoju fun igba diẹ ni oju kan. O wọle si ariyanjiyan lori iboju pẹlu Britt Baker, nikẹhin o padanu ere-idije kan si Baker ni AEW Full Gear. Priestley farahan lori 11 December 2019 edition of Dark, nibi ti o ti ṣẹgun nipasẹ alien Kris Statlander. 