 Complete the following phrase:  Despite his disappointing 2011, Massa remained with Ferrari for 2012. At the , Massa qualified 16th  a second behind teammate Alonso, who qualified twelfth  for his worst qualifying result since the 2010 Singapore Grand Prix, and the first time he qualified outside the top ten since the 2010 Japanese Grand Prix. Massa gained six places on the first lap, running as high as eighth in the early stages of the race, but suffered badly from tyre degradation and fell down the order before retiring from the race after a collision with Williams driver Bruno Senna; both drivers later agreed that it was a racing incident. In the , Massa qualified 12th and finished 15th, 1-minute 37 seconds behind his teammate Ferdo Alonso, who won the race. This result put Massa 19th in the Championship, whilst teammate Alonso was leading on 35 points. Saubers Sergio Pérez finished 2nd and there has been speculation linking Pérez to Massas seat. Massa was thirteenth at the before he scored his first points of the season with ninth at the . In Spain, Massa started sixteenth and finished fifteenth whilst teammate Alonso started and finished second, he also had a drive-through for ignoring yellow flags. He finished 6th in Monaco, and tenth in 