 Complete the following phrase:  In January, at the 2016 Tata Steel Chess Tournament, Caruana shared second along with Ding Liren with a score of 8 points out of 13 5-26, defeating Michael Adams, Wei Yi, Loek Van Wely, Pavel Eljanov, and Ding Liren, and losing to David Navara and Evgeny Tomashevsky. Had he defeated Tomashevsky, he would have at least tied for 1st place with Magnus Carlsen. Through this tournament, he gained 7 rating points and moved to 3 in the world. By March, as part of the qualification cycle for the World Chess Championship 2016, Caruana participated in the 