 While forward looking collective responsibility is thus not saddled with controversial metaphysical conditions in the way that its backward looking counterpart is, it is not without its own controversies. In some cases, these controversies are about what kinds of groups are capable of forward looking collective responsibility. Bill Wringe (Wringe 2014) and Felix Pinket (Pinket 2014) cover these controversies nicely. In other cases, they are about how—on what normative basis—we can ascribe forward collective looking responsibility in practice. What principles should we invoke to do so? How should we order these principles?