 Since Zebra* instantiates the disjunctive template, it is non-transmissive of at least first-time justification. In fact note that s acquires first-time justification for Q3 in this case if and only if (i) s has justification for P3 based on seeing that P3, (ii) s knows that P3 entails Q3, and (iii-ft) s acquires first-time justification for believing Q3 in virtue of (i) and (ii). Also note that (iii-ft) requires s’s justification for believing Q3 not to be independent of s’s justification for P3 based on seeing that P3. However, if (i) is true, the disjunctive template requires s to have justification for believing Q3 independent of s’s justification for P3 based on her seeing that P3. (For if s could not independently exclude that Q3 is false, given (d), (c) and (b), s could not exclude that the incompatible alternative R to P3, which s cannot subjectively distinguish from P3 on the ground of her seeing that P3, is true.) Thus, when the disjunctive template is instantiated, (i) and (iii-ft) cannot be satisfied at once. 