 Objections to the one-act approach have been raised by a number of commentators, in particular Allison, who partly endorses Ginsborg’s criticisms of Guyer, but raises difficulties for her reading of §9 (2001: 113–115) and, in particular, rejects the self-referential understanding of judgments of beauty as “inherently implausible” (2001: 115). Allison objects also that the one-act view fails to accommodate judgments of the ugly; for more on Kant’s views on the ugly, see  Section 2.3.6.  Criticisms of Ginsborg’s one-act approach are also to be found in Pippin (1996), Ameriks (1998), Palmer (2008), Vandenabeele (2008), Sweet (2009), Guyer (2017a), Makkai (2010 and 2021), and Berger (forthcoming); Ginsborg replies to Guyer’s criticism in her 2017.