  In the context of the experiencing of C-D, Hodgson holds that retention of C is definitely not a presentation, but rather a less vivid “representation” of C that is experienced with D. In the case of the single tone C, the retention of the earlier phase is quite different: it is indistinguishable from perception, or perception by “another name”.  Since Hodgson quotes the second passage in clarifying his position in an exchange with Stout (Hodgson 1900), he evidently believed it to be of some importance.  