 One remaining problem with Fishman and MacKay (2019) and Kniess’s (2019) reworking of Daniels’ (2008) approach is that they too are silent on the justice of residual health inequalities. This question is important, for while we have presented the free-standing and derivative approaches as alternatives, it is possible for the two approaches to be combined. Holding that inequalities in health are unjust because of their unjust causes does not preclude holding that they are unjust simply qua inequalities.