 Given a standard abstractionist theory of possible worlds, there is a possible world \(u\) that represents there being a popular 500 kg man \(x\), and there is another possible world \(v\) that represents there being an unpopular 500 kg man \(y\), where \(x\) at \(u\) has the same intrinsic properties as \(y\) at \(v\), and hence \(x\) at \(u\) is a duplicate of \(y\) at \(v\). Given this, (13) classifies being a popular man who is 500 kg as extrinsic.