 From the above analysis it is easy to conclude that the information-dependence template is satisfied by Moore* and akin proofs. In fact note that if E8 is evidence for both P8 and Not-Q8*, it seems correct to say that s can acquire a justification for believing P8 only if s has independent justification for disbelieving Not-Q8* and thus believing Q8*. Since Not-Q8* counts as a non-perceiving hypothesis for Pryor, this gives us a reason to doubt dogmatism (cf. White  2006).[15]