  Critics will ask, “If someone is justified out of the modest contrast class but not out of the extreme contrast class, is this believer just plain justified (period or without qualification)?” That, of course, depends on what it means to say that a believer is justified (without qualification). On one plausible account, to say that a believer is justified (without qualification) is to say that the believer is justified out of the relevant contrast class. But which contrast class is relevant when?