 Bede Rundle rejects an actual infinite. His grounds for doing so (the symmetry of the past and the future), if sustained, make   premise 7  false. He argues that the reasons often advanced for asymmetry, such as those given by Craig, are faulty. It is true that the past is not actual, but neither is the future. Likewise, that the past, having occurred, is unalterable is irrelevant, for neither is the future alterable. The only time that is real is the present. 