 The pragmatic approach to forward looking collective responsibility gestured to here is very valuable (and sound). But we cannot treat it in isolation from other approaches. In other words, we cannot simply replace causal responsibility with capacity for remedying a problem as a basis for ascribing forward looking responsibility. Instead, we have to incorporate other values and principles into our ascriptions of responsibility. What might they be? As things now stand, the value of fairness is frequently invoked, if not thoroughly explored, in this context. So, too, are the values of citizenship and collective obligation, as well as the principle of a social contract.