 Yet, despite such counterintuitive implications, utilitarianism tends to haunt even those of us who refuse to accept it, for there seems to be something quite compelling about its act-consequentialism (Berker 2013: 364; Foot 1985: 196; Korsgaard 1993 [1996: 225]). Of course, what exactly, if anything, is so compelling about it is controversial and, thus, something that we’ll need to consider below.