 (Dogs)  might at first be read without understanding, but might subsequently be read with understanding, giving rise to a phenomenal contrast case.  (Time)  can be read as a cliché or as a command at the insect races.  (Bar)  can be read as being about an aborted legal career or a trip around town. Again, the claim is that these different readings of the sentences give rise to different phenomenal experiences and that the best explanation of this is that thought has a proprietary and individuative phenomenology. 