 Views according to which life-friendly conditions are improbable in an epistemic sense due to the required fine-tuning are challenged to come to terms with the fact that, as a matter of fact, we have long known that our universe is life-friendly, which means that life-friendly conditions are not literally unexpected for us. As a consequence of this fact, the Bayesian version of the argument from fine-tuning for a designer as outlined in  Section 3.1  must adopt some solution to Bayesianism’s notorious problem of old evidence (Glymour 1980) because \(R\)—that the constants are right for life—is inevitably old evidence for us.