 Substantive and concise philosophical analyses of collective intentionality can be found in early Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy. These contributions have attracted increasing attention in recent years (Salice &amp; Schmid 2016; Moran &amp; Szanto 2016). Among the many relevant contributions and contributors (including Edmund Husserl, Edith Stein, and Jean-Paul Sartre), two stand out as particularly important: Gerda Walther (1923), and Max Scheler (1954 [1912]). The paradigm case in their (implicit) controversy is shared experience.