 As Wilson (2012) argues, however, that determinable facts are fixed by determinate facts is undermined by attention to the constitutive modal fact about any given determinable instance—say, that instance of red—that it is of a type that might have been differently determined—say, by scarlet rather than maroon. Here the suggestion is that no determinate fact or complex combination of such facts can provide a non-gerrymandered basis for such a constitutive modal fact.[40] 