 Another critical point of the dispositional view is that it does not take into account the intuitive fact that sounds are heard as unfolding over time and as having a duration, which is a clear sign of their being an event. Kulvicki (2014: 211) discusses this by elaborating on the plausibility of the argument of “perceptual seeming” that he attributes to the people who claim that sounds are events. The argument is based on the commonsensical idea for which if sound appears to have a duration, it is because it actually has a duration. This argument rests on three assumptions: 