 Despite the conflicting evidence, today there seems to be a general consensus that Harriet is the article’s primary author. It appears in the University of Toronto’s Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, but only in an appendix and under her name (H. T. Mill, [EW]). John Robson, the editor of Mill’s Collected Works, says that “most of the evidence” favors attributing it to her (Robson 1984, lxxv). Some commentators do dissent from this view, however (for example, Himmelfarb, 183–6; Warnock 1996, xxxv).