 A revelatory claim is a claim to the effect that a certain divine revelation (propositional or manifestational) has taken place—that God has revealed x to P (Menssen &amp; Sullivan 2007: 69). The existence of revelatory claims in different religions raises the question of epistemic justification: Could such claims be justified, and in that case, how? “Being justified” will here be understood in the very general sense of having “positive epistemic status” (the status of being “right, or proper, or acceptable, or approvable or up to standard” (Plantinga 1988: 1). 