 But what about those people who do not witness a miracle? Wahlberg argues that knowledge of Jesus’ resurrection could be available, through the biblical testimony, to non-witnesses, for example to people who live today. The biblical testimony about the resurrection, in turn, can be believed without doxastic irresponsibility by people who live today due to the historical-critical evidence that supports it and defeats the natural reasons for skepticism. According to Wahlberg, knowledge of the resurrection gained in this way would be non-inferentially justified by testimony (as a basic or sui generis source of justification), rather than by inference from the available historical-critical evidence. The latter evidence is not good enough for knowledge, but only for enabling responsible belief. 